L. L. Vasiliev

Experimental Studies of Mental Suggestion · pp. 13–18

CHAPTER I

THE ORIGIN AND DEVELOPMENT OF THE THEORY OF MENTAL SUGGESTION

Before proceeding to an account of our own investigations of mental suggestion, we should outline, if only briefly, the origin and history of this question.

The phenomenon of “mental suggestion”, or “direct transmission of thought”, or “telepathy”, consists in the transmission from one person to another of various kinds of impressions, thoughts, feelings, etc., and also in the possibility of inducing hypnotic sleep; in all these cases the result is achieved without words, at a distance, independently of the perception of any signals by the sense organs.

The first attempt to verify scientifically the reality of telepathic transmission belongs to the English physicist Barrett. In 1876 he made the first scientific report on this subject at a meeting of the British Association for the Advancement of Science (Some Phenomena Associated with Abnormal Conditions of Mind). After this, in 1882, the “Society for Psychical Research” (Society for Psychical Research) was founded in London. The first work of the members of this society consisted in collecting and studying authenticated cases relating to the transmission of thought and feeling at a distance. The results obtained were published in 1886 by Edmund Gurney, Frederic Myers and Frank Podmore.1

These authors were the first to propose the term “telepathy” (which literally means “feeling at a distance”) and introduced the division of telepathic phenomena into spontaneous (occurring of their own accord) and experimental (induced by the experimenter). By the second category they meant 14what is now called “mental suggestion”. The first kind of telepathy — spontaneous — covers various cases in which a person feels, and sometimes sees, what is happening to another person who is far away from him and is going through moments of the greatest nervous and mental strain.

Here is one of many (688) examples of this kind, taken from the collection of the London Society. A certain Warburton came to stay with his brother for a few days, did not find him at home, but found a note from him. “Instead of going to bed,” Warburton writes in his account, “I dozed off in an armchair, but at exactly 1 o'clock in the morning I suddenly woke up and cried out: ‘God, he has fallen!’ I had seen in a dream how my brother came out of the drawing-room into a brightly lit hall, caught his foot on a step at the top of the staircase and fell headlong forward onto his elbows and hands. Paying little attention to this occurrence, I dozed off again for half an hour and woke up when my brother came in, saying: ‘Oh, you are here, and I have only just nearly broken my neck. As I was leaving the ballroom, I caught my foot on a step and rolled headlong down the stairs.’” In the parapsychological literature such cases, more or less reliably attested by the testimony of witnesses, have been described in their hundreds and thousands.2

Manifestations of spontaneous telepathy cannot be repeated at will, and therefore the possibility of chance coincidence cannot be excluded from them. This was already clear to the first investigators of telepathic phenomena. That is why they turned to attempts to reproduce such phenomena experimentally.

The physiologist Ch. Richet carried out the first experiments devoted to proving the reality of mental suggestion by applying the methods of the calculus of probabilities.3 Since then mental suggestion has become the subject of numerous and many-sided experimental investigations. Scientists of various specialities — mathematicians, physicists, physiologists, psychologists, neuropathologists and psychiatrists — began to occupy themselves with it. At present an extensive literature is devoted to this question. The reality of mental suggestion has been and is recognized by a number of eminent scientists (S. Arrhenius, Camille Flammarion, W. McDougall, Ch. Richet, V. M. Bekhterev, P. P. Lazarev, K. E. Tsiolkovsky, H. Berger and others).

In the 1920s and 1930s a number of monographs on experimental telepathy were published abroad. Among them mention should be made of the works of Tischner (Tischner, 1925), Wasilewsky (Wasilewsky, 1921), Bruck (Bruck, 1925), Osty (Osty, 1932), Warcollier (Warcollier, 1926) and the book by the well-known 15American writer Upton Sinclair (Sinclair, 1930).3 These monographs contain extensive empirical material on the telepathic transmission of images of various objects, line drawings, playing cards, etc. The authors of the monographs are occupied with elucidating the optimal conditions and the psychical mechanisms of telepathic induction (action) and perception (reception). The problem of the physiological, and still more of the physical (energetic), nature of the phenomenon remains to this day little worked out experimentally.

Seventy to eighty years is usually a sufficient period for one idea or another to be rigorously proved or, on the contrary, refuted. With regard to telepathy we see neither the one nor the other. Present-day investigators of this question may be divided into three groups: some consider telepathic phenomena to be an already established fact; others (and they are the majority) do not consider telepathy experimentally proved, but acknowledge it to be theoretically conceivable or even highly probable; finally, the third group reject the very possibility of the telepathic phenomenon, proceeding in so doing from one or another a priori theoretical premise.

“Official science still treats telepathy as if it did not exist at all,” wrote Eugène Osty in one of his works.5 Persistent experimenters are not infrequently overtaken by complete disappointment: “. . .in the field of telepathy,” admits Gardner Murphy, “success does not exclude chance; after two years of experimenting the results turned out to be just as indefinite as they were at the beginning of the experiments.”6

All this creates around the question of telepathy an atmosphere of scepticism and pessimism. The phenomenon of telepathy apparently exists, but it has not proved possible to master it experimentally, and because of this it has not proved possible to elucidate the energetic nature of this phenomenon either. “Investigators have almost come to the assertion,” says Bozzano, “that telepathy is a riddle which becomes the less accessible to understanding the more it is studied.”7 This state of affairs is explained by a number of causes.

First, still only a few scientific workers venture to take up this question seriously. The investigator must overcome a certain inner resistance in himself before he will agree to see in telepathic phenomena a subject worthy of scientific investigation. 16Second, despite numerous attempts, it has still not proved possible to elucidate the optimal psychophysiological conditions of telepathic induction and perception, a knowledge of which would make the results of telepathic experiments constant, and therefore fully convincing. In other words, investigators do not yet have at their disposal a sufficiently reliable and precise method of mental suggestion.

Third, the use of laboratory instrumental methods of investigation not infrequently prevents the person making the suggestion (the telepathic agent, the inductor) from concentrating on the object of suggestion, and usually disconcerts the subject (the percipient, the one who perceives the suggestion), thereby lowering the latter's ability to perceive the mentally transmitted suggestion.

Finally, fourth, until recently telepathic phenomena differing in their nature have been confused with one another; manifesting themselves not infrequently in one and the same experiment, they mask or confound each other.

According to present-day conceptions, it is necessary to distinguish at least two such phenomena:

1. Transmission of thought (transmission de pensée) — the active transmission of the maximally intense thought of the inductor to the percipient, who plays in this case the role of a passive receiver of the “telepatheme” transmitted to him. This variety of the telepathic phenomenon may otherwise be called mental suggestion (suggestion mentale).4

2. Thought reading (lecture de pensée) — a phenomenon in which the active role belongs no longer to the inductor but to the percipient. In this case the percipient telepathically perceives some content or other of the hidden (latent) psyche of the inductor, for example some event from his life or some present perception on which the inductor himself is not concentrating his attention at the given moment. This variety of the telepathic phenomenon is not infrequently designated by the term “telemnesia”.9

Such a distinction of concepts is at present generally accepted in the foreign literature on this question. Some authors go still further, holding that even under the term “transmission of thought” two qualitatively different phenomena are concealed.

The first — “transmission of thought at a short distance” — represents, according to Bozzano, “an active influence of the inductor's psyche on the subconscious sphere of the percipient”, and serves as the object of ordinary telepathic experiments. The second — “telepathy in the proper sense of the word” — does not depend, or only slightly 17depends, on the magnitude of the distance between inductor and percipient; it represents the result of the influence of the conscious or subconscious sphere of the inductor on the psyche of the percipient, and manifests itself predominantly spontaneously, in the form of so-called telepathic hallucinations.5

Thus, according to present-day conceptions, even in the simplest telepathic experiment phenomena of various kinds and of different degrees of complexity may manifest themselves. For example, in intentionally induced mental suggestion there are present elements of “telepathy in the proper sense”, elements of “telemnesia”, and even of so-called “telesthesia”.6

This shows with what a complex set of mental phenomena the experimenter may be confronted when conducting what would seem to be the simplest experiments in mental suggestion. It also shows what difficulties the investigator encounters in attempting a psychological analysis of the data obtained in the experiment.

The complexity of the telepathic phenomenon, ignorance of the psychophysiological conditions necessary and sufficient for mastering this phenomenon experimentally, the absence of a sufficiently precise and reliable method — all this, in its turn, creates extraordinary obstacles to elucidating the biophysical (energetic) nature of telepathy.

On this last question there exist at present two mutually opposed views.

In the opinion of the Italian investigator Ernesto Bozzano mentioned above, mental suggestion at a short distance is based on a process of propagation from the brain of the inductor to the brain of the percipient of peculiar psychophysical vibrations, whose nature is qualitatively different from the ordinary forms of energy known to physicists.7 As regards cases of spontaneous telepathy, here, in this author's opinion, we are dealing no longer with an energetic influence but with “a supernormal subconscious faculty inherent in the agent”, i.e. with “direct communication between two spiritual entities” (communication direct entre deux mentalités).8 This statement must, of course, be recognised as idealistic.

The opposite views are expressed by the defenders of the electromagnetic hypothesis of the telepathic phenomenon. As far as we know, this scientific materialist hypothesis was 18first put forward by Houston about 70 years ago.9 This author's conceptions were based on the phenomenon of electrical resonance, discovered shortly before by Hertz in 1888. A nervous-psychical process, accompanied by the flow of bioelectric currents in the active brain of the inductor, gives rise in the surrounding medium to electromagnetic waves of a definite length (brain radio waves), which reach the brain of the percipient and excite in it an analogous process of a nervous-psychical character. In short, the phenomenon of transmission of thought reduces to a process of “intercerebral (inter-brain) electromagnetic induction”.

The further development of this conception was promoted, on the one hand, by the powerful development of radio engineering and, on the other, by the accumulation of knowledge about the bioelectric currents inseparably connected with the process of excitation of brain cells and nerve conductors.

The pioneer of this work in our country was Academician V. M. Bekhterev, who did not doubt the existence of telepathic phenomena and was the first of the Russian scientists to put forward the electromagnetic hypothesis to explain them.

The theory of electromagnetic radiations of the brain served as a working hypothesis for our investigation and, as such, required a more thorough and critical examination.

Notes

  1. E. Gurney, F. Myers, F. Podmore. Phantasms of the Living. London, 1886. (A Russian translation exists: E. Gurney, F. Myers, F. Podmore. Phantasms of the Living (in Russian). St. Petersburg, 1893.) ↩
  2. See R. Amadou. La parapsychologie. Paris, 1954, pp. 81–88. 3: Ch. Richet. La suggestion mentale et le calcul des probabilités. Revue philos., 1884, n° 18, p. 609. ↩
  3. Bibliographical data on these works are given in Chapter V, footnote 1. 5: E. Osty. La Télépathie experimentale. Revue métapsychique, 1925, n° 1, p. 5. 6: G. Murphy. Quoted from E. Osty. Revue métapsychique, 1925, n° 1, p. 13. 7: E. Bozzano. Considérations et hypothèses au sujet des phénomènes télépathiques. Revue métapsychique, 1933, n° 3, p. 145. ↩
  4. Terms introduced as early as by Prof. Ch. Richet and Dr. Julian Ochorowicz. 9: R. Warcollier. La Télépathie active et passive. Revue métapsychique, 1924, n° 5. ↩
  5. E. Bozzano. Considérations et hypothèses au sujet des phénomènes télépatiques. Revue métapsychique, 1933, n° 3, p. 145. ↩
  6. A term introduced by Myers in place of the obsolete and inexact expression “clairvoyance” (F. Myers. Human personality. New impression. New York, 1909). ↩
  7. A similar hypothesis had been expressed still earlier by Frederic Myers, who supposed that here we are dealing with vibrations of a “metaetheric” medium. ↩
  8. See footnote 7. ↩
  9. A paper read to the Section of Electricity of the Franklin Institute (USA) on 1 March 1892 (E. Houston. La Radiation Cérébrale. In: A. de Rochas. L'extériorisation de la sensibilité. Paris, 1899, pp. 215–225). ↩