L. L. Vasiliev

Experimental Studies of Mental Suggestion · pp. 19–33

CHAPTER II

THE ELECTROMAGNETIC THEORY OF MENTAL SUGGESTION AND ITS EXPERIMENTAL FOUNDATIONS

The study of the electrical processes taking place in the brain, and in particular in the cortex of the cerebral hemispheres, was begun by the work of Caton and, in our country, by V. Ya. Danilevsky in the mid-1870s. At the present time the scientific literature on the biocurrents of the brain is enormous. We shall mention here only a few results of electrophysiological investigations of the cerebral cortex that bear directly on the subject of this chapter.1

These investigations, in the form in which they are carried out at the present time, were initiated in 1925 by the work of V. V. Pravdich-Neminsky. Analysing records of the biocurrents of the exposed cortex of the dog, he was the first to establish several types of oscillations of the electrical potential led off from the visual or motor areas of the cortex. In 1929 Hans Berger demonstrated the possibility of recording the electrical activity of the human cortex from the skin of the head through the intact skull, and made records of the biocurrents of the brain both in healthy persons and in nervous and mental patients. He called such a record an electroencephalogram (abbreviated EEG). The EEG differs somewhat from the record of biocurrents taken from the surface of the exposed cortex — the electrocorticogram (ECoG) — since, in passing through the dura mater, the skull, the aponeurosis, the muscles and the skin of the head, the biocurrents of the cortex are naturally modified and weakened, on average by a factor of approximately 10.

The electrical activity of the cortex recorded as an EEG from the surface of the skull is usually 10–15 μV (microvolts) in amplitude. The oscillations of the cortical biopotentials occur spontaneously, i.e. automatically, without the necessary participation of any reflex influences from the sense organs. In the human EEG these oscillations are represented by the following rhythms.

201. α\alpha (alpha) rhythm: frequency F=7.5÷13F = 7.5 \div 13 c/s; amplitude A=10÷50A = 10 \div 50 μV and Amax⁡=100A_{\max} = 100 μV. The amplitude of the alpha rhythm is affected by age, hunger and emotional excitement. In frequency the α\alpha rhythm remains constant over a long period of life (from 20 to 70 years). During wakefulness the α\alpha rhythm is connected with attention. Depression of the α\alpha rhythm can be produced by any kind of stimulation of the sense organs. The most characteristic is the depression of the α\alpha rhythm on opening the eyes (stimulation of the retina by light).

2. β\beta (beta) rhythm: frequency F=15÷25F = 15 \div 25 c/s; amplitude A=25÷30A = 25 \div 30 μV. The beta rhythm is better revealed when the α\alpha rhythm is suppressed by external stimuli; their amplitude then rises somewhat. The maximum amplitude of the β\beta rhythm is found when recording directly from the precentral gyri of the cortex.

3. Θ\Theta (theta) rhythm: frequency F=4÷7F = 4 \div 7 c/s; amplitude A=10÷30A = 10 \div 30 μV. It is characteristic of the theta rhythm that it is connected with the emotions. It appears in the EEG of children during a bad mood, and in adults it is connected with a state of aggression. In this case the amplitude of the Θ\Theta rhythm increases.

4. δ\delta (delta) rhythm: frequency F=0.5÷3F = 0.5 \div 3 c/s; amplitude AA reaches approximately up to 1000 μV. The delta rhythm is a sign of cortical pathology if it appears in the waking state. Its appearance during sleep is normal.

5. Fast oscillations of the spike (peak) type: frequency F=500÷1000F = 500 \div 1000 c/s; amplitude A=150÷200A = 150 \div 200 μV. These oscillations are localized maximally in the temporal lobes. Some authors regard them as the result of a local increase in the excitability of the nerve cells.

What amplitude can the highest-voltage potentials reach, and on what does the amplitude depend?

A high-voltage discharge in the cortex may be due to the following factors: 1) the total number of neurons excited at the given moment; 2) the degree of synchronization (simultaneity) in phase of the discharges of the many cells that make up the given summated discharge; 3) the degree of depolarization of each cell (since cell potentials do not obey the all-or-none law). If we assume that the last factor is constant and that each cell produces its maximum potential, then the height of the potential will be proportional to the number of cells excited synchronously. In this case large potentials can be ascribed to hypersynchronization. The same number of active cells discharging at random, asynchronously, can produce only a low-voltage potential. In hypersynchronization potentials exceeding the normal by 10–20 times may be recorded.

The electrical activity of the cerebral cortex is undoubtedly connected in some way with mental activity. In all those cases in which a person loses consciousness for any reason, a slow δ\delta rhythm of high amplitude 21appears in the EEG. If the loss of consciousness passes into death, the oscillations of potential gradually weaken and die away. In each subject the EEG has certain individual features, evidently connected with the peculiarities of his neuropsychic make-up. However, to decipher from the EEG the content of the psyche, of consciousness, i.e. precisely what the subject is experiencing, what he is thinking about, what he is feeling at the given moment, is impossible and will hardly ever become possible.

For our subject it is important now to emphasize that electrical currents of an oscillatory character issue from the brain and can be picked up on the surface of the skull; from this it follows that the existence of electromagnetic waves or fields generated by these currents around the human head must be recognized not only as possible but as a necessary fact. The question is whether the electromagnetic waves of the brain can be picked up by modern sensitive radio receivers.

This problem was put forward in concrete form by Academician P. P. Lazarev (1920), who wrote the following lines on the subject: “We must thus regard it as possible to capture thought in external space in the form of an electromagnetic wave, and this problem is one of the most interesting problems of biological physics. Of course, a priori one can point to the enormous difficulties of detecting these waves. A number of years of intensive work will be required in order to discover these phenomena directly by experiment, but in any case their necessity is predicted by the ionic theory of excitation. The transmission of the process of thought in space provides definite grounds for explaining the phenomena of hypnosis and appears undoubtedly to be of great interest from the theoretical and practical point of view.”2

Taking into account the rhythm of the cortical biocurrents (10–50 c/s) and the velocity of propagation of electromagnetic waves (300 thousand km per 1 sec), Lazarev determined the length of the brain waves as 6–30 thousand km. It has not so far proved possible to record such long waves around the human head experimentally.

To the question of what kind of energy we are dealing with in mental suggestion, Academician V. M. Bekhterev wrote the following: “This question would, of course, require detailed elucidation, but, bearing in mind that the nervous current is accompanied by an electronegative oscillation or action current and that this action current itself exhibits oscillations, owing to the phase of decomposition of the nervous substance, accompanied by ionization, and the phase of restoration that follows it, there is reason to suppose that here

22we are dealing with a manifestation of electromagnetic energy and, most probably, with Hertzian rays.”3

This quotation shows that, unlike P. P. Lazarev, V. M. Bekhterev considered that mental suggestion is effected not by low-frequency fields kilometres long, but by short high-frequency electromagnetic waves.

This supposition of Bekhterev's is in agreement with the results of the experiments of the Italian neurologist Prof. Cazzamalli.4 In his experiments of 1923–1925 a screening chamber constructed on the principle of the Faraday cage was used. The casing, made of sheets of lead (1.5 mm thick), was, in the author's opinion, supposed to protect the interior of the chamber completely from the penetration of external electromagnetic fields into it. Placed in the chamber were a subject capable of falling into a deep hypnotic sleep under the influence of verbal suggestion, and a valve radio receiver with a loop or linear aerial situated 50–70 cm from the subject's head.

The radio receiver, tuned to a short wavelength (from 10 to 100 m, and in a number of experiments from 0.7 to 10 m), was connected by a wire to a pair of headphones worn by the experimenter, who was either outside the chamber or, in some experiments, inside it. Before the beginning of an experiment the operation of all the instruments was checked. After this the subject was brought into the chamber, and the check of the instruments was repeated with the subject in a lying position.

As long as the subject remained in the waking state, the radio receiver gave no signals whatever. But as soon as the subject fell into hypnosis and, under the influence of suggestion, began to hallucinate, various sounds were heard in the headphones, indicating the formation of radio waves inside the chamber. The sounds resembled now ordinary radiotelegraph signals, now an intermittent whistle, now the sound of a violin, and, according to the author's assertion, differed from the sounds due to one or another defect of the apparatus. The sounds grew stronger as the suggested hallucinations intensified and died away as they weakened. When the subject was awakened the sounds immediately ceased, but on renewal of the hypnotic state they began again.

These experiments, carried out with the participation of an experienced radio engineer on a number of subjects (usually patients suffering from one or another psychoneurosis), convinced Cazzamalli that during the course of strong, emotionally coloured neuropsychic processes evoked in hypnosis the human brain 23radiates into the surrounding space electromagnetic energy in the form of aperiodic and damped radio waves with a length of 0.7–100 m.

On the methodological side these first experiments of Cazzamalli met with a number of substantial objections. The authoritative physicists Breneau5 and A. A. Petrovsky6 considered the conclusions of the Italian scientist not entirely convincing for the following reasons. “With such a high degree of sensitivity as that to which the radio receiver has to be set in these experiments, the slightest changes in the arrangement of the parts of the apparatus, the approach of a hand or even internal changes taking place in the batteries may be sufficient for the onset of self-generation of radio waves, which often occurs in radio practice.” When radio receivers of the type with which Cazzamalli worked are used, “the experimenter inevitably has before him a generator of electromagnetic waves. These waves, being repeatedly reflected from the metal walls of the chamber and interfering with one another, may considerably complicate the picture of the phenomenon.”

Moreover, “since the subject is in the field of electromagnetic waves radiated by the radio receiver itself, and is a conductor, electrical currents of an oscillatory character must inevitably arise in him, as a result of which his body will create its own electromagnetic field acting back upon the receiver.” For the human body the conditions of resonance, under which this phenomenon occurs particularly noticeably, arise for waves about 3 m long.7 With longer or excessively short waves the system moves away from resonance, and the phenomena of reaction, by which Cazzamalli's observations may be explained, are weakened.8

In his subsequent experiments of 1926–1933 Cazzamalli considerably improved and refined his method, taking into account a number of critical remarks made to him. Listening to the waves through a telephone was replaced by their galvanometric recording.9 In his last work10 Cazzamalli used an electromagnetic oscillograph provided with an amplifying installation and a recording apparatus for photographic registration of the effects on cinematographic film. 24In the first series of experiments the subject, lying on a couch in the screening chamber, was not permitted to make any movements. When he pictured to himself with plastic clarity persons or events that affected him deeply emotionally, or fell asleep and had dreams that excited him, or, finally, was subjected to suggested hallucinations, the oscillograph in many cases began to record electromagnetic waves picked up by the receiver.

In another series of experiments the subject was asked to bring himself into a state of the fullest possible rest and “mental passivity”. This state was suddenly interrupted by the experimenter, who asked the subject to think of persons or events evoking in him the most intense possible

Fig. 1. Oscillogram of “brain radio waves” (after Cazzamalli).

Fig. 1. Oscillogram of “brain radio waves” (after Cazzamalli).

reaction of an emotional character. In this case, after a short latent period, the pointer of the oscillograph likewise began to move, and an oscillogram was recorded in the form of a rhythmic series of damped oscillations of a definite frequency; in other cases the oscillations were aperiodic, i.e., had a variable wavelength. Fig. 1 shows an oscillogram recorded in an experiment with a subject who had been asked to picture to himself an attack in which he had once taken part during the First World War11 (from Cazzamalli's work of 1933).

The appearance of oscillations in response to some stimulus was called by the author the “psychoradiant reflex”. It is analogous to the “psychogalvanic reflex”, long known to science, with the difference, however, that here, in response to an affecting stimulus, what arises and is recorded is not bioelectric currents but a series of electromagnetic oscillations picked up by an instrument at a certain distance from the subject.

It is precisely the brain radio waves (“radioondes cerebrales”) detected in the experiments described that Cazzamalli regards as the energy factor which effects the telepathic 25transmission of thought. The radio waves radiated by the brain of the inductor penetrate into the brain of the percipient and excite those of its centres which are tuned to the corresponding wavelength (“brain radio”, “intercerebral induction”).

Cazzamalli's work was not an absolute novelty; as always in such cases, predecessors were found. As early as the first half of the last century the famous English physicists Davy and Faraday established that during the discharge (shock) of an electric fish (Torpedo) a magnetic needle was deflected and steel needles were magnetized in accordance with the same laws that govern currents of ordinary electricity. This meant that “animal electricity”, as it was then called, can act at a distance.

Among the attempts to detect the electric field created by the human organism, the work of Heidweiller12 should be mentioned. In his experiments he used a quadrant electrometer connected to a receiving plate. Movements of a person near the plate caused changes in the readings of the electrometer. More distinct data of the same kind were subsequently established by the German physicists Sauerbruch and Schumann:13 contraction, or even mere static tension, of the muscles of the upper or lower limbs of a person was accompanied by the appearance of a low-frequency electric field which could be picked up at a distance of 3 m. We shall return to these experiments in Chapter IV.

Such low-frequency fields can be generated by the ordinary biocurrents of working skeletal muscles. As is well known, the rhythm of muscle biocurrents does not exceed 40–50 c/s. But what bioelectric processes could generate ultra-high-frequency brain waves? Electrophysiologists to this day know of no such high-frequency electrical oscillations in the EEG and ECG as could directly generate Cazzamalli's metre and decimetre brain waves.

Some authors — B. B. Kazhinsky, A. V. Leontovich, G. Lakhovsky — attempted to get round this difficulty by constructing an ingenious “histophysical” hypothesis.14

Kazhinsky proceeded from the following premises. Apáthy had at one time expressed the idea that the conductor of the electric action current is the neurofibrils, while the Schwann and myelin sheaths are insulators. Bethe confirmed

26this experimentally. Bekhterev supposed that the endings of the dendrites play the role of condensers in the transmission of excitation across synapses. All this gave Kazhinsky occasion to put forward the theoretical conception of a vibrator circuit of neurons.

For the circuit of a transmitter it is sufficient to have a capacitance and an inductance. Kazhinsky considers that the capacitance is created by the sheaths of the nerve, while the inductance is represented by the spiral of the neuron. Kazhinsky also draws his conception of the receiver from histology. In his opinion, the role of the aerial is played by “Krause's end bulbs”, and the role of detectors and amplifiers by the ganglion cells of the nerves of the heart (which, as he writes, work after the fashion of triodes). Since the fundamental frequency of the nerve centres (according to Verworn's measurements) is 12 c/s, the wavelength is correspondingly equal to 25,000 km. It is known from radio engineering that an open symmetrical vibrator radiates a wave 4 times the length of the vibrator itself. Consequently, the vibrator in the brain would have to be no less than 6,000 km in extent, which is difficult to admit.13 Kazhinsky considers that there are also closed circuits in the nervous system.14

Kazhinsky's main conclusions come down to the following:

1. Both the open and the closed oscillatory circuits of neurons can be mutually coupled in the inductive sense, and their action in that case is accompanied by the appearance of combined oscillations, as a result of which an interfered electromagnetic wave is radiated.

2. The whole nervous system represents one common 27circuit of neuron chains radiating one common electromagnetic wave.

3. Every thought is accompanied by the appearance of electromagnetic waves in the central nervous system.

4. The electromagnetic waves of one brain can be inductively received by another brain and can reproduce in it the corresponding neuro-psychic experience.

From our point of view, Kazhinsky's histological premises are unconvincing, since the whole argument is built on an analogy between the morphological structure of the nervous system and the structure of physical receivers and transmitters. This analogy may prove to be a purely external one, and in general all inferences by analogy are unreliable. Nevertheless, B. B. Kazhinsky's ideas were sympathetically received by the eminent histologist and physiologist A. V. Leontovich. Beginning in 1928, Academician Leontovich tried to find in the histological structure of neurons the conditions necessary and sufficient for the generation of ultra-short radio waves corresponding in their length to Cazzamalli's waves. Leontovich regarded the various structural formations of nervous tissue (pericellular fibres, neurofibrils, cell processes and their lamellar endings) as conductors of bioelectric current possessing self-induction and capacitance. From this point of view, the nervous system consists of an enormous number of radio apparatuses of microscopic size, capable of generating and receiving ultra-short radio waves. Thus, according to Leontovich, the radio waves generated by the pericellular fibres can be picked up by the intracellular neurofibrils. In this way the transmission of excitation within the brain, from one neuron to another, is effected by means of electromagnetic energy (intracerebral induction).15 Micrometric measurements and mathematical calculations led the author to the conclusion that the length of the radio waves generated in this case corresponds approximately to the length of Cazzamalli's waves.

Cazzamalli's experiments and Leontovich's calculations would seem to constitute solid support for the electromagnetic hypothesis of mental suggestion. And yet this hypothesis, so attractive in its apparent simplicity, continues to meet with a number of serious objections.

Let us assume that brain radio waves really exist, that the inductor's brain radiates them during a telepathic experiment, and that these waves penetrate into the percipient's brain. But is their intensity sufficient for them to act as a stimulus to the percipient's nerve cells? And this is absolutely necessary: otherwise their action will prove to be below the threshold of stimulation and will consequently remain without any psychophysiological effect whatever.

28This important question was first raised by Prof. V. K. Arkadiev.16 Making use of the equations of theoretical physics, this author attempted to calculate approximately the current strength, and then the magnitude of the field, that could correspond to brain radiations. The results of the calculations proved to be far from encouraging: a current strength of the order of 10−1810^{-18} ampere, and an energy carried by the electromagnetic radiation of the brain of the order of 6.54⋅10−246.54 \cdot 10^{-24} erg, i.e. considerably less than the minimal light energy perceived by the most sensitive receptor, the eye (2⋅10−102 \cdot 10^{-10} erg).

It is improbable that brain cells should be more sensitive to the action of radio waves than the sense organs are to the action of the stimuli adequate for them — the eye to light, the ear to sound, and so on.

We see, Arkadiev concludes his exposition, that the magnitude of the field or the current strength that could occur with electromagnetic influences from the inductor's brain are too negligible to produce any physiological effect in the percipient's brain. “A considerably greater action on the nervous centres of man,” the author remarks, “ought to be exerted by the electromagnetic field of those electrical installations amid which modern man lives and works. To this question, which was raised more than a quarter of a century ago, one is obliged to answer in the negative up to the present time: we do not notice any beneficial, harmful or other action on the human organism of those electric and magnetic fields that are created by any electrical wiring or installation.”17

To all this the following considerations must also be added. The radio waves described by Cazzamalli can hardly exert an exciting action on the percipient's brain, not only because they are too weak, but also because they possess an enormous frequency of rhythm. According to the law of stimulation established for alternating currents (the so-called Nernst square-root law), high-frequency currents, and the high-frequency electromagnetic fields generated by them, possess a stimulating action that is the smaller, the higher the frequency of their periods:

r=an,r = \dfrac{a}{\sqrt{n}},

29where rr is the threshold strength of stimulation, aa the amplitude and nn the frequency of the alternating current. Hence the remarkable fact of the physiological inactivity of high-frequency currents, discovered by the Yugoslav physicist Tesla. Hence also the explanation of those observations on the physiological action of high-frequency electromagnetic fields on the functional state of the nerve, the brain and the whole organism that have been made in a number of laboratories. High-frequency (metre-band) radio waves of sufficient power are capable of killing the nerve-muscle apparatus and the whole organism without thereby producing the slightest signs of nervous excitation or exaltation. The dying of the preparation and the death of the organism are explained by their overheating, which develops in consequence of the appearance of Foucault currents in them.

Low-frequency fields (with wavelengths of the order of several thousand kilometres), on the contrary, exert a strongly stimulating action on isolated nerves and cause an increase in the excitability of nerves and nervous centres situated under the conditions of their natural position in the organism.18

It is especially important to note that low-frequency electromagnetic fields can, apparently, act upon the cortex of the cerebral hemispheres of man, and thereby also upon higher nervous activity. In this respect great attention is deserved by the work of F. P. Petrov, carried out at the Pavlov Institute of Physiology of the Academy of Sciences of the USSR.19

In two healthy subjects the author succeeded in elaborating a conditioned motor defensive reflex to the imperceptible (“subsensory”) action of a low-frequency electromagnetic field (200 c/s). Reinforcement was provided by stimulation of the subject's fingers with electric current. The voltage on the vibrator placed above the subject's head reached 30,000 V. To elaborate the conditioned reflex, the electromagnetic field was switched on without the subject's noticing it, and then electrocutaneous unconditioned stimulation was added to the action of the field. The intervals between individual trials lasted from 0.5 to 3 min.

In the subject G. (40 years old) the first conditioned response to the electromagnetic field was obtained at the 150th trial (conditioned reflexes to perceptible signals, to light and to a bell, were elaborated in this subject with the same difficulty). In the other subject (25 years old) the first conditioned reflex appeared at the 67th trial. Subsequently the conditioned reflex became consolidated in both subjects, but it did not possess great stability. 30Then an attempt was made to elaborate conditioned inhibition to the electromagnetic field. In the subject G. a conditioned defensive reflex to red light was first elaborated and consolidated. Subsequently the red light was reinforced from time to time by the electrocutaneous stimulus, while the combination of electromagnetic field plus red light was not reinforced. As a result, conditioned inhibition was elaborated very slowly (only at the 36th experiment), and even this was not stable.

F. P. Petrov explains the slowness of formation and the instability of both the positive and the negative conditioned reflexes in this case by the fact that a low-frequency electromagnetic field is not an adequate stimulus for the receptors present in the human organism. In this connection he refers to the statement of Academician K. M. Bykov that, when a stimulus is inadequate, even if it is perceptible, a conditioned reflex is either not formed at all or appears after a large number of combinations and is unstable and weak.

Recently, at the Department of Physiology of Higher Nervous Activity of Moscow University, it was shown in experiments on fish (crucian carp) that defensive and food-procuring conditioned reflexes can be elaborated also to the imperceptible action of a magnetic field. The threshold of perception of the magnetic field proved to be 10–30 oersted. In the majority of birds, in particular in pigeons, it was not possible to elaborate a conditioned reflex to the magnetic field. In other birds, for example in bullfinches, the magnetic field caused, as in fish, a sharp increase (by 2–4 times) in motor activity.20

“Animals,” remarks Yu. A. Kholodov, “probably have no special receptors for the perception of the magnetic field, but the part most sensitive to it, as to other penetrating factors (the UHF electromagnetic field, X-rays, etc.), is the diencephalon.” This proposition is supported by the author's own observations: after injury to the diencephalon (with the other parts of the central nervous system preserved) the conditioned reflexes formed in fish to the magnetic field were disturbed; by the direct action of the magnetic field on the diencephalon it was possible to evoke Sechenov inhibition of spinal reflexes in frogs, and so on. Of importance also is the following conclusion of Yu. A. Kholodov: experiments with prolonged action of a constant magnetic field showed that animals perceive not only a change in its intensity but also its constant strength.

There are experimental data (as yet unpublished) showing that a conditioned reflex can be elaborated also to the imperceptible action of electromagnetic waves of ultra-high 31frequency. Perhaps, like the magnetic field, this physical agent is also capable of acting on the brain directly, i.e., without the mediation of any sense organs. At the present time it has been established experimentally that a temporary connection between cortical neurons can be formed without the mediation of receptors, by direct repeated stimulation (for example, with electric current) of a sensory and at the same time a motor area of the cerebral cortex.21 There is nothing here that contradicts the reflex theory and I. P. Pavlov's teaching on conditioned reflexes. At the same time, the facts cited support the conception of “brain radio”.

This conception is supported still more by the experiments of the Canadian scientist Penfield.22 He showed that by electrical stimulation of certain areas of the cortex of the cerebral hemispheres it is possible not only to form conditioned reflexes but also to evoke particular psychic experiences. Penfield carried out his investigations on patients with focal epilepsy. The stimulating apparatus was a generator of rectangular electrical impulses with a frequency from 60 to 300 cycles per second. Stimulation was effected by means of microelectrodes applied near the diseased focus in a region of the temporal lobe of the cortex not yet damaged by the disease. The patient would then declare that he was, as it were, living through again one of the episodes of his past life. When the stimulating electrodes were moved by only 1 mm, this episode was replaced by another. The patient reported his psychic experiences to the experimenter, while being aware at the same time that he was lying on the operating table.

Thus psychic experiences which had once already been evoked in the subject's life in the ordinary reflex way can be evoked a second time without the participation of any receptors or reflex arcs, by direct electrical stimulation of strictly defined neurons of the cerebral cortex. It remains to suppose that in “direct transmission of thought” the same neurons are selectively stimulated no longer by a locally applied current, but by electromagnetic waves of a definite length produced by another person's brain.

No less importance is attached by the defenders of the electromagnetic hypothesis of mental suggestion to experiments in which the suggesting “inductor” or the “percipient” is placed in a screening metal chamber. It was to be expected beforehand that 32screening by metal would stop, or at least appreciably weaken, the manifestations of mental suggestion, if it is really transmitted by electromagnetic waves. As far as we know, the first few experiments of this kind were carried out by B. B. Kazhinsky jointly with V. L. Durov on trained dogs in the mid-1920s.23 In 61% of the experiments with screening of the inductor the mental influence on the behaviour of the animals ceased, but in 39% of the same experiments it continued to take effect — a rather indefinite result.

Another series of experiments was carried out by the physician and hypnologist T. V. Gurshtein together with B. B. Kazhinsky in 1926. The experiments made use of a chamber with double walls, floor and ceiling made of sheets of brass and roofing iron. It was mounted on insulators and could be earthed by means of a switch (in the experimenters' view, closing the switch, i.e., earthing the walls of the chamber, enhanced its insulating properties). The percipient was placed in the chamber; Dr. Gurshtein, standing outside the chamber in the same room, would take some object in his hands and ask the percipient: “What am I holding in my hand?” or “What am I smelling?”, “What do you feel?” and so on (the suggester meanwhile inhaled the smell of eau de Cologne or pricked himself in the hand). Only 14 such experiments were carried out, and it is difficult to draw any conclusion from them about the significance of screening: the percipient sometimes gave a correct answer both with the chamber earthed and with it unearthed. For example, Dr. Gurshtein holds a red cross before his eyes and asks: “What do you see?” The answer, with the chamber earthed: “A cross.” In the same experiment, to the question “What colour do you see?” the answer, with the chamber unearthed: “Dark red.”

One more series of 10 experiments with the use of screening was performed by T. V. Gurshtein together with L. A. Vodolazsky in 1936, i.e., at the time when we were already completing our investigations at the Leningrad Brain Institute. In 1937 Dr. Gurshtein reported the results of his experiments at a meeting of the Moscow Society of Psychiatrists and Neuropathologists.24 This series of experiments was carried out more carefully than the preceding ones and deserves greater attention. We shall return to it in Chapter IV, which is devoted to the mental suggestion of motor acts.

In the same chapter we shall also discuss yet another attempt to show experimentally that screening with metal hinders the transmission of mental suggestion. This attempt was made by 33one of Academician Lazarev's co-workers, S. Ya. Turlygin. He set out his results in 1939 at a meeting of the Biophysical section of the Moscow Society of Naturalists in a paper “On the Radiation of the Human Nervous System”. For the present it is important for us to note only one of the speaker's conclusions, namely the following. Non-verbal suggestion is effected by electromagnetic waves, one of whose wavelengths, measured with the aid of a diffraction grating of parallel wires, proved to be about 2 mm (more precisely, from 1.88 to 2.1 mm).25

Thus the electromagnetic hypothesis of mental suggestion was enriched by yet another variant: electromagnetic waves of millimetre length take part in effecting suggestion at a distance, and it is allegedly to them that the principal role in this process belongs.26

All that has been set forth in this chapter shows that the electromagnetic hypothesis of mental suggestion not only cannot be considered factually substantiated, but meets with a number of difficulties and contradictions that are far from having been removed. Nevertheless, when we began our investigations, we were guided by this hypothesis. At that time we did not yet doubt its truth.

Notes

  1. For more detail see the recently published booklet: P. I. Gulyaev. Electrical Processes of the Human Cerebral Cortex (in Russian). Leningrad University Press, 1960. ↩
  2. P. P. Lazarev. Current Problems of Biological Physics (in Russian). Moscow, 1920, pp. 28–29; Idem. Physico-Chemical Foundations of Higher Nervous Activity (in Russian). Moscow, 1922; Idem. “Russian Physiological Journal” (in Russian), 1923, vol. 5, issue 4–6, p. 312. ↩
  3. V. M. Bekhterev. On experiments on “mental” influence on the behaviour of animals (in Russian). Problems of the Study and Education of Personality, issue 2. Petrograd, 1920, pp. 230–265; Same author. In: Collective Reflexology (in Russian). “Kolos” Publishers, 1921, pp. 122–126; 3rd ed., GIZ, 1926, p. 38. ↩
  4. F. Cazzamalli. Phénomènes télépsychiques et radiations cérébrales. Revue métapsychique, 1925, n° 4, p. 3. ↩
  5. Director of the French General Wireless Telegraph Company. ↩
  6. A. A. Petrovsky. Telepsychic phenomena and brain radiations. “Telephony and Telegraphy without Wires” (in Russian), 1926, No. 34, p. 61. ↩
  7. N. A. Skritsky and V. V. Lermontov. First communication on the influence of the human body on receivers and transmitters of the short-wave band (in Russian). Berlin, 1926. ↩
  8. A. A. Petrovsky. Telepsychic phenomena and brain radiations. “Telephony and Telegraphy without Wires” (in Russian), 1926, No. 34, p. 61. ↩
  9. F. Cazzamalli. Esperience, argomenti e problemi di biofisica cerebrale. Genova, 1929. ↩
  10. F. Cazzamalli. Giornale di Psichiatria e di Neurologia. Estratto. Fasc. I, I Trimestre, 1933. ↩
  11. The physical part of these experiments was conducted by the engineer Gnezutta, a co-worker of Marconi, and the technician Rosa. ↩
  12. Quoted from W. Schumann. Über electrische Felder physiologischen Ursprungs. Zs. für Technische Physik. Leipzig, 1928, Nr 3, S. 315. 13: F. Sauerbruch u. W. Schumann. Über electrische Felder in der Umgebung lebender Wesen. Zs. für Technische Physik, 1928, Nr 3, S. 96. 14: B. B. Kazhinsky. Transmission of Thoughts (in Russian). Proceedings of the Association of Naturalists. Supplement 2. Moscow, 1923; B. B. Kazhinsky. Biological Radio Communication (in Russian). Kiev, Academy of Sciences of the Ukrainian SSR Press, 1962; A. V. Leontovitch. Comptes rendues de l'Académie française. Paris, 1928; A. V. Leontovich. The neuron as an alternating-current apparatus. Abstracts of the XV International Congress of Physiologists (in Russian), Moscow–Leningrad, 1935; G. Lakhovsky. L'oscillations cellulaires. Paris, 1931. ↩
  13. The same objection was also made by the founder of cybernetics, Norbert Wiener (see Tekhnika molodezhi, 1961, No. 3, p. 30). However, the Polish physicist and parapsychologist Stefan Manczarski comes to a different conclusion: according to his data, the human brain can produce “broad-band radiation”, from centimetre waves to waves tens and hundreds of kilometres long (S. Manczarski. Zastosowanie cybernetyki i radiofizyki w parapsychologii. «Przeglad telekomunikacyjny», 1961, № 11, p. 325). ↩
  14. The physiologist Lorente de Nó showed that the anatomical arrangement of neurons in the cerebral cortex makes possible a continuous circulation of impulses in complex neuronal pathways, which he called closed self-exciting chains. Circulating continuously along a specific chain of neurons, the impulses form a specific pattern of activity in space and in time, which may serve as the basis for equally specific neuro-psychical phenomena, for example various images, feelings, acts of will, etc. At the same time it is quite admissible that such specific patterns of circulating impulses generate combinations of electromagnetic waves equally specific in their composition, which at a distance, in another brain, may induce corresponding “patterns” of impulses circulating along neuronal chains, and consequently also the sensations or images corresponding to them. It must be added to this that modern radio engineering possesses the means for generating complex in form, specifically different combinations of electrical impulses and fields, similar to the specific “patterns of nervous activity” as understood by electrophysiologists. (Lorente de Nó. Studies on the Structure of the Cerebral Cortex. I. the Area Enterhinalis. Journ. Psychol. Neurol., v. 45, 1933, p. 381. See also J. C. Eccles. The neurophysiological basis of mind, 1953, pp. 217–219.) ↩
  15. As distinct from intercerebral induction, that is, transmission from one brain to another brain, which Academician Leontovich does not touch upon. ↩
  16. V. Arkadiev. On the electromagnetic hypothesis of the transmission of mental suggestion (in Russian). Journal of Applied Physics, 1924, vol. 1, p. 215. ↩
  17. Ibid., pp. 219–220. — It should be noted, however, that observations have recently been made showing that powerful short-wave installations do not leave without influence the neuro-psychical sphere of the personnel operating them, producing a number of pathological symptoms (headache, a feeling of pressure in the region of the forehead, insomnia, weakness with trembling of the hands and legs). New data on this question can be found in the collection of experimental works edited by Prof. A. V. Triumfov, “On the Biological Action of the Superhigh-Frequency Electromagnetic Field” (in Russian) (Leningrad, 1957). ↩
  18. V. Ya. Danilevsky. Investigations of the Physiological Action of Electricity at a Distance (in Russian), vol. I. Kharkov, 1900; vol. 2. Kharkov, 1901; F. P. Petrov. The action of an electromagnetic field on isolated organs (in Russian). In the collection “Physico-Chemical Foundations of Nervous Activity”. Proceedings of the Brain Institute, Leningrad, 1935, p. 97. ↩
  19. F. P. Petrov. The action of a low-frequency electromagnetic field on higher nervous activity (in Russian). Proceedings of the I. P. Pavlov Institute of Physiology of the Academy of Sciences of the USSR, vol. 1. Leningrad, 1952, p. 369. ↩
  20. Yu. A. Kholodov. Towards a physiological analysis of the action of the magnetic field on animals (in Russian). Author's abstract of a candidate's dissertation, Moscow State University, 1958. ↩
  21. M. Yu. Ulyanov. On the establishment of a temporary connection under direct electrical stimulation of the cerebral cortex of an animal in acute experiment (in Russian). Scientific Notes of the Gorky State Medical Institute, issue IX, 1959. ↩
  22. W. Penfield. Psychical phenomena evoked by stimulation of the cortex (in Russian). Journal of Higher Nervous Activity, vol. VI, issue 4, 1956; W. Penfield and H. Jasper. Epilepsy and the Functional Anatomy of the Human Brain (in Russian). Foreign Literature Publishing House, 1958. ↩
  23. The first report of these experiments appeared in the article by A. L. Chizhov “Transmission of Thought at a Distance (the Brain as a Radio Apparatus)” (in Russian) in the journal Ekho (No. 20, 1925). ↩
  24. The paper was entitled “On the Question of the Electromagnetic Radiation of Man”. It was not published in print; it is quoted here from a surviving typewritten copy. ↩
  25. A brief summary of this paper is given in the article by B. V. Krayukhin “Is Electroinduction Possible in the Tissues of a Living Organism?” (in Russian) (Collection in Memory of A. V. Leontovich (in Ukrainian). Kiev, 1948, p. 88.) For more detail see S. Ya. Turlygin. Radiation of Microwaves (λ≅2\lambda \cong 2 mm) by the Human Organism (in Russian). Bulletin of Experimental Biology and Medicine, 1942, vol. 14, issue 4, No. 10, p. 63. ↩
  26. For some new considerations on the question of the electromagnetic fields of the brain see the article by R. M. Granovskaya under the same title (in Russian) (Proceedings of the Leningrad Society of Naturalists, 1961, vol. LXXII, issue 1, p. 111). ↩