L. L. Vasiliev

Experimental Studies of Mental Suggestion · pp. 34–45

CHAPTER III

PHYSICAL APPARATUS. CONTROL AND PRELIMINARY EXPERIMENTS. PLAN OF THE INVESTIGATION

Thus, we saw the central task of the investigation as coming as close as possible to elucidating the physical nature of the energy that brings about the phenomenon of mental suggestion. As already noted, we adopted the electromagnetic theory of this phenomenon as our working hypothesis. It therefore seemed to us not without interest to carry out a series of control experiments aimed at establishing the fact of brain radiations.

First of all we decided to repeat the experiments of Cazzamalli, the results of which, as far as is known, had not yet been sufficiently confirmed by other investigators.1 For this purpose, following the indications drawn from his works, we constructed the appropriate apparatus, to the description of which we shall now proceed.

As has already been pointed out, in order to eliminate external influences (stray electromagnetic fields), Cazzamalli carried out his experiments in a chamber whose walls were covered with lead sheets 1.5 mm thick. Since, at the electromagnetic wavelengths we expected (1–10 m), the material of the screen plays no essential role, we decided to use sheet iron as the screening material. The chamber we built (henceforth we shall call it the Faraday cage, or chamber No. 1) consisted of a wooden frame covered with sheets of roofing iron about 1 mm thick. The seams between the sheets were sealed with lead foil. The chamber had the following dimensions: length 2.2 m, width 1.4 m, height 2.0 m; its general appearance is shown in the accompanying photograph (Fig. 2). Inside the chamber

Fig. 2. Faraday cage. Inside the cage, the couch for the percipient and the radio receiver (on the table) can be seen.

Fig. 2. The Faraday cage. Inside the chamber the couch for the percipient and the radio receiver (on the table) can be seen.

36were placed a couch for the subject, a small table for the apparatus and a chair for the experimenter. Entry into the chamber was through a door, which was also covered with iron and closed tightly, without any gaps.

According to Cazzamalli's descriptions, he used a receiver built on a single-ended three-point circuit. The receiver had a tuning range from a wavelength of 70 cm to 5 m. The receiver had four valves. The first valve was a regenerative detector, the second and third were low-frequency amplifiers with transformer coupling, and the fourth was a second detector, which rectified the audio-frequency current and worked into a loop oscillograph.

Although our aim was to check Cazzamalli's experiments, we nevertheless decided to depart somewhat from an exact copy of his apparatus. The reasons for this were as follows:

Firstly, the lack of an oscillograph and our uncertainty about a positive outcome of the experiments made us abandon (at least for the time being) the construction of a recording device and compelled us to register the effect (if it should appear) subjectively, by ear.

Secondly, we replaced Hartley's single-ended circuit by a push-pull circuit with inductive coupling of grids and anodes. This departure was caused by the circumstance that we were unable to make the valves at our disposal work in the regenerative-detector mode on very short waves. For the same reason, the shortest wavelength of our receiving device was 2.78 m. On shorter waves we were unable to obtain stable operation with any of the circuits we tried. Single-ended circuits did not give us stable operation even on longer waves. Owing to these circumstances we decided to settle on the push-pull circuit with inductive feedback.

The general circuit of our receiving device is shown in Fig. 3. As can be seen, the receiver, in addition to the two receiving valves, had two further stages of low-frequency amplification on transformers. The amplifying valves were of the UB-110 type. The oscillatory circuit was inductively coupled to an aperiodic aerial stretched along the chamber above the couch, at a height of 70 cm. Reception was by headphones.

To check the operation of the receiver and the screening properties of the chamber we had built, we assembled a push-pull generator working on valves of the UT-1 type or similar ones. The generator could be supplied either directly with alternating current from the city mains or from accumulators. The circuit of the generator is shown in Fig. 4. The generator had no radiating system of any kind. The wavelengths of the receiver and the transmitter were measured, as is usual in ultra-short-wave technique, by means of a Lecher system. 37The experiments showed that the operation of the generator could be freely received anywhere in the laboratory, although neither the receiver nor the transmitter had any aerials.

Fig. 3. Diagram of the radio receiver (after Hartley) used in the experiments of Cazzamalli and of the author. БН — filament battery; + БА — anode battery.

Fig. 3. Circuit of the radio receiver (after Hartley) used in the experiments of Cazzamalli and of the author. BN — filament battery; + BA — anode battery.

Before carrying out Cazzamalli's experiments we tested the screening properties of the Faraday cage. For this purpose the experimenter was placed with the receiver in the chamber and, with the door open, tuned in to the wave of the generator. The chamber door was then gradually closed, while the observer followed the strength of reception. The experiments showed that with the door tightly closed it was impossible to detect any signs of reception. On the other hand, if the door was not closed tightly enough, if even a small (0.5–1 mm) gap remained, reception appeared at once and was fairly loud. In these experiments the generator was in the same room as the chamber, at a distance of 1–2 m from it. This test, carried out on several wavelengths (from 2.8 to 15 m), convinced us that with the door tightly closed no external fields are observed in the chamber.

Fig. 4. Ultra-short-wave generator used in the author's experiments. + БА — anode battery.

Fig. 4. Ultra-short-wave generator used in the author's experiments. + BA — anode battery.

As has already been pointed out, Cazzamalli at first carried out his experiments with subjects in a hypnotic state, to whom a strong emotional experience was suggested. Later he detected an electromagnetic field also in cases when the subject was not in hypnosis but

37 38was mentally reliving some deeply stirring moment of his life.

We carried out a series of similar experiments.

In some of them the subject was placed on a couch in the Faraday cage together with the experimenter and the hypnotist and was put into hypnosis by one method or another. Then some emotion of a pleasant or unpleasant character was verbally suggested to him, which was followed on his part by a mimic-somatic and verbal reaction that was at times rather violent. Throughout the experiment the experimenter (R. I. Skaryatin) listened through the telephone, slowly passing through the entire range of the receiver.

In other experiments there were two persons in the Faraday cage: the subject and the experimenter. The former lay on a couch beneath the antenna and tried to picture to himself and, as it were, to live through again the most stirring and significant events of his past. The experimenter meanwhile made observations similar to those described above.

All these experiments gave a negative result: in not a single experiment did we detect any unusual sounds or noises in the telephones of the receiver. Only faint rustlings were heard, such as are inherent in every regenerative receiver and arise from the incomplete constancy of the electrical processes in the receiving apparatus.

What, then, are the reasons for the failure of our experiments? The explanation should apparently be sought not in the departures from an exact copy of Cazzamalli's apparatus. The replacement of lead by iron as the screening material cannot affect the emission (if it exists) of electromagnetic waves by the subject's brain, since it is known from radio-engineering practice that the influence of the material of the screen shows itself at most in the wavelength of the emitted oscillations and in the decrement of the oscillatory circuit. This influence, however, can be clearly observed only when the screen is very close to the coil or capacitor making up the oscillatory circuit. Further, the use of a push-pull circuit instead of a single-ended one likewise could not have affected the sensitivity of the receiver, since these circuits are known to possess equal sensitivity.

The somewhat longer waves, compared with the waves on which Cazzamalli worked, are also hardly likely to have affected the results, since Cazzamalli obtained reception not only on waves of about 1 m, as he reports in his second paper (1929), but also on longer ones, up to 10 m (see his first paper in 1925).

It will be appropriate to note here that the photographs of the receiving apparatus given by Cazzamalli in his 1929 paper give grounds for doubting that he conducted his observations on waves of 1 m. Namely, the dimensions of the turns making up the self-inductance of the oscillatory circuit of his receiver cannot possibly 39provide the value of self-inductance needed for tuning to a wave of 1 m, even taking into account only the interelectrode capacitance of the first valve. Moreover, we know of no description of a receiver for so short a wave working on the feedback principle.

Thus, if Cazzamalli is right, the negative result of our experiments must be sought in an unfortunate choice of subjects.

The negative result of our check on Cazzamalli's experiments prompted us to undertake a search for other physical indicators of radiations produced by the organism. Thus, we put to experimental test the assertion of a certain electrical engineer that he had allegedly succeeded in recording electromagnetic emissions of the brain with a wavelength of the order of millimetres.2 To test this assertion, special installations were constructed in our laboratory by this engineer. A description of these installations and of the experiments carried out with them is not given here, since the results obtained were negative.

It must be said, however, that we did not attach any special significance to all these preliminary experiments. Even if they had given a quite definite positive result, even if the existence of Cazzamalli's brain waves had been indisputably established by these experiments, the question would still have remained open: is it precisely they, Cazzamalli's waves, and not some other regions of the vast electromagnetic spectrum, that play the role of the factor which effects telepathic transmission? The whole point of the matter consisted precisely in giving an answer, founded on experiments, to this cardinal question.

For this it was necessary to carry out some decisive experiment, a kind of “experimentum crucis”. The idea of such an experiment, fully approved by our physicist consultants Academician V. F. Mitkevich and Prof. A. A. Petrovsky, presented itself to us in the following form:

1. To select the method of mental suggestion most suitable for the given case — a method which would give us experimental data that were as constant as possible and amenable to statistical treatment.

2. Following the selected method, to carry out a sufficiently large number of experiments on subjects suitable for telepathic experiments and to prove statistically the presence of mental suggestion in the results obtained.

3. To repeat the same experiments, using the same method of mental suggestion that had proved itself, and on the same 40subjects, but with the subjects (or the inductor) placed in a chamber screening them from the influence of electromagnetic fields, and above all from Cazzamalli's supposed brain radio waves.

If the experiments with screening led to a complete, or at least partial but statistically significant, reduction of the telepathic effect obtained in the experiments without screening, then it could be said with confidence that telepathic transmission is effected by means of electromagnetic radiations from the inductor's brain.

If, on the contrary, it turned out that screening does not reduce the percentage of successful experiments in mental suggestion, then the opposite proposition could be asserted: electromagnetic waves retained by the walls of the screening chamber (including Cazzamalli's brain rays) play no part in the process of telepathic transmission. In that case, by changing the material of the walls of the chamber (replacing iron by lead, etc.), we could subsequently resolve the same question for other regions of the electromagnetic spectrum as well.

Such was our plan. In the literature available to us at the time we could note only one attempt similar to ours. We have in mind the experiments carried out in 1923 by the engineer B. B. Kazhinsky together with V. L. Durov,3 but these experiments seemed to us methodologically unsatisfactory, as will be discussed in the next chapter.

Not fully trusting the screening properties of the Faraday cage already at our disposal, we decided to build a new chamber, a “total screening chamber” (Chamber No. 2), following in doing so the instructions of Academician V. F. Mitkevich.

This chamber was a rectangular parallelepiped 1.7 m high, 0.62 m wide and 0.90 m long, consisting of two halves, an upper and a lower. Each of the halves consisted of a wooden frame covered with iron sheets about 1 mm thick; all the seams and joints of the sheets were carefully soldered; the upper half (the hood) was suspended on a steel cable passing over a pulley screwed into the ceiling. The weight of the upper half was counterbalanced by a 16 kg weight. In this way the iron hood could easily be raised or lowered onto the lower half of the chamber. Along the upper edge of the latter a trough was fitted, into which mercury was poured. When the upper half of the chamber was lowered, its lower edge, which for better contact was made of brass and amalgamated, entered this mercury. This arrangement ensured the absence of gaps between the two halves and thereby the total screening of the space inside 41the chamber from external electromagnetic fields. Inside the chamber there were a chair for the experimenter and a small shelf serving as a table. The chamber was lit by a small lamp of the automobile type, fed from a storage battery placed there as well.

For communication between the inductor inside the chamber and the “outside world”, a contact device was fitted on the outside of the chamber. The contact was closed when the inductor pressed on the iron sheathing of the chamber at the appropriate spot. This contact closed the circuit of an electromagnetic signal marker[^a], which served as the signal. In addition, when our last experiments were being set up, an electromagnetic sounder was installed outside the chamber. By means of this sounder the inductor could be informed of the onset of the percipient's reaction (the hypnotic state or waking).

Thus the chamber was a completely hermetic iron shell, without gaps anywhere and into which not a single wire was led.

To test the hermeticity of the chamber, a metal branch pipe with a stopcock was soldered into its wall in the lower half. Air was pumped into the chamber through this pipe, and the pressure inside the chamber could be followed on a manometer attached to it. The tests showed that the pressure in the chamber remained constant for two hours.

The “electrical hermeticity” was tested by us in the following way. The ultrashort-wave generator described above was placed inside the chamber together with its batteries. An observer, moving round the chamber with a receiver, tried to detect any penetration of electromagnetic energy from the chamber to the outside. The experiment was then altered in that the observer was placed with the receiver inside the chamber and tried to receive signals from the generator located outside it. Fig. 5 shows the external appearance of the total screening chamber. The upper half of the chamber is raised; the generator placed inside the chamber is visible. On the left, on a small table, stands the receiver. On the front wall of the lower half of the chamber the signalling contact device can be seen.

Control experiments carried out at the same wavelengths as in the case of the Faraday cage showed that no signs of reception could be detected when the lower edge of the upper half was immersed in the mercury at all points. Reception appeared at once as soon as even a narrow gap formed anywhere. A round opening, made specially in the wall of the chamber for these test experiments, did not let electromagnetic energy out if its area was not greater than 1.5–2.0 cm2^2. Reception, though weak, appeared only when a piece of wire was introduced into the chamber through this opening. 42A series of experiments similar to those described above convinced us that the total screening chamber we had built does indeed isolate, in the electrical sense, the experimenter placed in it from external fields, and also will not let the electromagnetic energy radiated by his brain during the experiment pass into the outer space. For still greater certainty

Fig. 5. Iron chamber of “total screening” (for the inductor). Its upper half is raised on a pulley. Inside is the generator (see Fig. 4). On the small table to the left is the radio receiver (see Fig. 3). On the right, on a stand, is the manometer for testing the airtightness of the chamber when it is closed, i.e. when the upper half is lowered.

Fig. 5. The iron chamber of “total screening” (for the inductor). Its upper half is raised on the pulley. Inside is the generator (see Fig. 4). On the left, on a small table, is the radio receiver (see Fig. 3). On the right, on a stand, is the manometer for testing the hermeticity of the chamber when it is closed, i.e. when the upper half is lowered.

we carried out a check calculation of the screening properties of our chambers.

It is known from the theory of electricity that an electromagnetic field penetrates into a conducting medium to a depth 43approximately equal to one wavelength, this length having to be calculated for the given conducting medium.

As is known, the wavelength (λ\lambda) is related to its velocity of propagation vv as follows:

λ=vT,(1)\lambda = vT, \tag{1}

where TT is the period of oscillation in sec.

The velocity of propagation, in turn, depends on the physical constants of the given medium, this dependence being given by the equation (in the case of a plane wave)

v=1γμT.(2)v = \dfrac{1}{\sqrt{\gamma\mu T}}. \tag{2}

In this equation γ\gamma is the specific electrical conductivity of the medium, μ\mu its magnetic permeability, and TT, as before, the period of oscillation.

Substituting the expression for the velocity of propagation into equation (1), we obtain

λ=Tγμ=Sμf,(3)\lambda = \sqrt{\dfrac{T}{\gamma\mu}} = \sqrt{\dfrac{S}{\mu f}}, \tag{3}

where SS is the specific resistance of the medium in units of the CGSμ\mu system, and ff is the frequency of oscillation.

Such will be the wavelength in the conductor, and such, it may be assumed, will also be the depth of penetration of the electromagnetic field into it. Calculating by formula (3) the depth of penetration of the current into iron (taking γ≅10−4\gamma \cong 10^{-4} and μ≅103\mu \cong 10^{3}), we find that for an oscillation frequency of f=3⋅109f = 3 \cdot 10^{9} c/s (wavelength in air equal to 1 m) the depth of penetration of the current is expressed in ten-thousandths of a millimetre. For a wavelength in air of 100 m we obtain a depth of penetration of 0.018 mm, and for a wave of 10,000 m approximately 0.2 mm.

Thus the calculation shows that the whole range of waves, from millimetre waves to kilometre waves, will be completely screened by our iron chamber. Experimental confirmation of this, incidentally, is to be found in everyday radio-engineering practice.4

As regards waves shorter than ultraviolet, conclusions about their screening must be drawn with a certain caution. It is known that hard X-rays penetrate metal. Consequently, formula (3) may be 44applied only up to a certain frequency. Investigations by some authors (Glagoleva-Arkadieva and others) show that when the wavelength becomes comparable with the dimensions of molecules, the phenomena of propagation of the electromagnetic field differ from the phenomena of propagation under ordinary conditions.

In the same way, formula (3) cannot be applied to the case of a static field, since it follows from this formula that at f=0f = 0 the depth of penetration must be equal to infinity.

Summing up what has been set out, we are obliged to conclude that if, when the total screening chamber is used, the telepathic effect is not obtained, then the energy causing it will have to be regarded as electromagnetic energy with a frequency lower than that of X-rays, i.e. 102210^{22} c/s. Conversely, if the telepathic effect is obtained, and if this energy is regarded as being of electromagnetic nature, then it will have to be sought in the region of frequencies corresponding to rays with a wavelength shorter than that of soft X-rays, or with a wavelength measured in kilometres.

Our second concern consisted in finding subjects suitable for the experiments — telepathic percipients. This work was carried out by us at the very beginning of our investigations (1932). The subjects were mainly patients of Dr. A. V. Dubrovsky, aged from 19 to 40, who suffered from hysteria or hystero-neurasthenia and were easily brought into a state of hypnosis (for the most part of the somnambulistic type). From among them we selected those most suitable for experiments in mental suggestion. These proved to be two hysterical women 35 years of age — E. M. Ivanova and K. G. Fedorova.

In parallel with this, the experimenters accumulated experience and acquired skill in mental suggestion (telepathic induction), which requires above all the ability to concentrate attention to the utmost on the “telepatheme” being transmitted, and is far from a simple and an extremely tiring matter. The role of inductor was performed by I. F. Tomashevsky, A. V. Dubrovsky and, in some cases, by the director of the work, L. L. Vasiliev.

Finally, the last, most important and at the same time most difficult task consisted in finding a method of mental suggestion that would correspond better than all others to the aims of the projected psychophysical experiments.

It should be noted that in the literature of the question one can find descriptions of numerous and varied methods of mental suggestion, which, according to the content and character of the “telepatheme” transmitted, fall into three groups: motor, sensory and hypnogenic.

Of these, we first applied mental suggestion of simple motor acts and mental suggestion of visual 45perceptions and sensations; then — mental putting to sleep and mental awakening.

In many cases these methods gave us fairly definite positive results, testifying to the presence of the factor of mental suggestion. But the first two methods proved less suitable for the purposes of psychophysical investigation. As experience showed, they either required a considerable time or led to an indefinite “intermediate” result and, owing to this, did not make it possible to obtain mass numerical material suitable for statistical treatment, to which particular importance has to be attached in experiments on mental suggestion. Therefore, of the methods enumerated, we mainly applied mental putting to sleep and mental awakening — the method which gave us the most constant positive results in the course of our investigation.

The following chapters, which form the main content of the present investigation, are devoted to a successive description of these methods and of the results obtained with their help.

Notes

  1. According to information received in 1960 from the Paris Metapsychical Institute, Cazzamalli’s experiments have remained unconfirmed. ↩
  2. As was already pointed out in the preceding chapter, S. Ya. Turlygin also arrived at the same result. ↩
  3. See footnotes: 25 to Chapter II and 22 to Chapter IV. ↩
  4. This was written about 30 years ago. It is now known that long (kilometre) electromagnetic waves do pass, in attenuated form, through an iron wall 1 mm thick. About 80% of the energy of a low-frequency electromagnetic field (50 c/s) is reflected from the walls of the chamber. The remaining 20% of the field energy, on passing through the iron wall of the chamber 1 mm thick, is attenuated approximately 3 times in intensity and 33 times in power. (Data of the engineer I. P. Ionov.) ↩