L. L. Vasiliev

Experimental Studies of Mental Suggestion · pp. 3–11

Feci quod potui faciant meliora potentes.

I have done what I could; let those who can do better.

PREFACE

This little book, now offered to the reader, sets out experimental investigations of telepathic phenomena that I carried out, with some interruptions, over a period of 40 years, partly on my own but more often together with colleagues. I began these investigations at the Leningrad Institute for the Study of the Brain and Mental Activity, at first at the suggestion of the founder of the institute, Prof. V. M. Bekhterev, and then, after his death at the end of 1927, independently, on my own initiative.

The author joined the Brain Institute as a still novice physiologist in the autumn of 1921, at the very time when V. M. Bekhterev, together with the well-known animal trainer V. L. Durov and his own co-workers, was enthusiastically engaged in experiments on the mental suggestion of previously thought-out motor acts to trained dogs. Vladimir Mikhailovich attached great importance to these experiments and devoted a voluminous article in the scientific transactions of the institute to their description.1

The results of experiments by his co-workers on the same question were also published there.2 I too had occasion to take part in some of these experiments.3

In the same years Bekhterev published the results of his experiments in mental suggestion to an 18-year-old girl distinguished by 4heightened nervous impressionability (guessing an object thought of from among 7–12 objects laid out on a table).4

To continue and extend experiments of this kind, Bekhterev in the spring of 1922 established at the Brain Institute a special Commission for the Study of Mental Suggestion. Its members included psychologists (A. K. Borsuk, N. D. Nikitin, V. I. Rabinovich), physician-hypnologists (V. N. Finne, N. A. Panov), physiologists (L. L. Vasiliev, V. M. Karasik), physicists (A. A. Petrovsky, V. A. Poderni), the philosopher S. I. Povarnin, and others.

The members of this Commission concentrated their attention mainly on the study of phenomena of two categories: mental suggestion in experiments on man, and the psychophysiological action of a magnetic field on a hypnotic subject. The results were reported to V. M. Bekhterev, who found the achievements of the Commission worthy of attention and included the papers of the Commission's members in the programme of the Second All-Russian Congress on Psychoneurology, held in January 1924 in Petrograd. At the morning session of the section of hypnosis, suggestion and psychotherapy of this congress on 8 January, the following papers presented by the Commission were heard:

1) A. K. Borsuk, “The present state of the question of mental suggestion abroad”.

2) V. A. Poderni, “Investigation of the Phenomena of Intercerebral Induction and Perception” (results of the experimental work of the Commission).

3) L. L. Vasiliev and V. N. Finne, “On the question of the psychophysiological action of a magnetic field” (results of the experimental work of the Commission).

In addition to the programme, the same session also heard the papers of K. I. Platonov, “On the power of the gaze” (with a demonstration of the mental putting to sleep and mental awakening of the patient Mikhailova), and of P. V. Kapterev, “On the question of the nature of hypnotic phenomena”.

The resolution of the congress noted in a special point the necessity of further investigations of so-called mental suggestion and the desirability of Russian scientists taking part in the work of the International Committee for Psychical Research, organized abroad shortly before (in 1921).5 This committee, created on the initiative of the eminent French physiologist Charles Richet, comprised local (national) committees from 19 countries of Europe and America. In subsequent years the number of national committees steadily increased (in 1935 there were already 26 of them).

The wish of the congress was soon fulfilled. The secretary-general of the International Committee, the 5Dane Carl Vett, arrived in the Soviet Union with a proposal to form, within the International Committee, a “Russian Committee for Psychical Research” as well.5 On the recommendation of A. V. Lunacharsky, then People's Commissar of Education, such a committee for the USSR was created. Its original members were Academician V. M. Bekhterev, Academician P. P. Lazarev, the director of the Moscow Darwin Museum A. E. Kots, and the Leningrad psychiatrist G. V. Reits, known abroad for his works on mental suggestion. After the death of V. M. Bekhterev I too was included in this committee, as his pupil and follower.

The All-Russian Congress of Psychoneurologists not only recognized the scientific significance of the work carried out by the Commission, but also spoke in favour of its extension. However, by that time the Commission itself had already ceased to exist (it had been closed at the end of 1923, i.e. just before the opening of the congress).

The implementation of the congress resolution was entrusted to the Society of Neurology, Reflexology, Hypnology and Biological Physics attached to the Brain Institute. At a plenary session of the Society in March 1926, chaired by V. M. Bekhterev, the following papers were heard:

1) A. K. Chekhovsky, “On the question of the direct transmission of thought at a distance” (experimental), and

2) L. L. Vasiliev, “The biophysical foundations of the direct transmission of thought” (theoretical).

Prof. Vasiliev's paper, which set forth a materialist approach to the phenomenon of mental suggestion, was published in popular form in the journal Vestnik znaniya (No. 7, 1926). In connection with the first paper, the board of the Society commissioned a group of its members to verify experimentally the method and results of the speaker. The control experiments undertaken gave no definite results. Equally indefinite results were given by the verification experiments carried out with the participation of Academicians V. M. Bekhterev and V. F. Mitkevich on Dr. K. I. Platonov's subject Mikhailova, who by that time had already developed a tendency to fall into autohypnosis, which interfered with the conduct of these experiments. On the other hand, a series of experiments with positive and clear-cut results was successfully carried out in the same year on the subject Kuzmina in the nervous department of the Pamyat 25 Oktyabrya (In Memory of 25 October) hospital (these experiments are described in Chapter IV).

For a more systematic study of the question of mental suggestion and the biophysical problems connected with it, in October 1926 the Society set up a special Commission, which it named the Experimental Commission on Hypnology and Biophysics. The chairman of this Commission was V. M. Bekhterev; its members included, besides the above-mentioned speakers at the II Congress on Psychoneurology, physicists (Prof. A. A. Petrovsky, Prof. B. L. 6Rozing), physiologists (Prof. G. P. Zelenyi, I. F. Tomashevsky), psychiatrists (Prof. K. I. Povarnin, G. V. Reits, A. V. Dubrovsky), philosophers (S. I. Povarnin and I. A. Borichevsky), and others. In the 2 years of its existence the Commission (it ceased to exist after the death of V. M. Bekhterev at the end of December 1927) held 16 scientific meetings. Its members carried out the following experimental and methodological work:

1) objective methods of analysis and control were worked out for cases of the “spontaneous” manifestation of mental suggestion (Borichevsky);

2) hundreds of experiments were performed relating to the phenomena of so-called “guessing of visual images” (Reits);

3) the phenomena of false recognition were investigated experimentally (Borichevsky);

4) a series of experiments on “guessing” was carried out with the subject P., which gave a negative result (Reits and Dubrovsky, at Bekhterev's suggestion);

5) a series of experiments was set up on the training of the effect of neuromuscular hyperexcitability (after Charcot) in hypnosis by the method of conjunctive (conditioned) reflexes (Vasiliev, Poderni and Finne);

6) a series of experiments was performed with the piercing of various parts of the body with simultaneous recording of respiration, pulse and blood pressure (Vasiliev and Dubrovsky, in connection with the demonstrations of To-Ram);

7) a series of experiments was set up on the question of the influence of the hands on a movable metal pointer (Vasiliev and Dubrovsky, at Bekhterev's suggestion).

In the summer of 1928 I had occasion to be on a scientific mission to Germany and France. In Paris I acquainted myself with the investigations of the International Metapsychical Institute founded by Ch. Richet, and in Berlin with the work of the Institute of Parapsychology, which had just then been founded, and I established scientific contact with prominent foreign investigators of telepathic phenomena — Eugène Osty, A. Rouhier, Karl Bruck and others. Correspondence with workers at these centres for the study of parapsychical phenomena continued for a long time and was of great help to me in my subsequent investigations of mental suggestion.

In 1932 the Bekhterev Brain Institute, then headed by the well-known psychiatrist Prof. V. P. Osipov6 (who, it must be said, did not admit the possibility of the existence of telepathy), received the task of beginning an experimental investigation of telepathy with the aim of elucidating, if possible, its physical nature: electromagnetic waves of what length effect the “brain radio”, i.e. the transmission of information from one brain to another brain, if such transmission really exists? It should 7be noted that in those years (1923–1933) wide renown was gained by the experiments of the Italian psychiatrist Cazzamalli, who claimed to have discovered brain radio waves of centimetre and metre length. Cazzamalli's investigations were regarded as a solid confirmation of the electromagnetic theory of telepathic phenomena.

The Director of the Brain Institute accepted this task for execution. I was entrusted with the scientific direction of the work. Under the dome of the Institute building a secluded room was set aside for the creation in it of a special laboratory, equipped with the physical and physiological apparatus needed for conducting the experiments. The work was carried out by a team of research workers — I. F. Tomashevsky (physiologist), A. V. Dubrovsky (physician and hypnologist) and R. I. Skaryatin (physicist-engineer); in one of the series of experiments the physiologist G. Yu. Belitsky also took part. The consultants on the physical side of the work were authorities in radio engineering who were prominent at that time: one of them (Academician V. F. Mitkevich) admitted the possibility of telepathic influence and himself set up experiments on mental suggestion, using a simple method he had worked out;7 the other consultant (Prof. M. V. Shuleikin), on the contrary, was sceptical of the very problem and subjected all our experiments to severe criticism. In this way he rendered the work a great service. In striving to satisfy the at times captious demands of a strict critic, the laboratory team spared no effort to improve the design of the experiments more and more.

The investigations were carried out over the course of five and a half years (until 1938). During this time a large body of experimental material was accumulated, which the authors set down in writing in the form of three reports: 1) “The psychophysiological foundations of the telepathic phenomenon” (1934), 2) “On the physical foundations of mental suggestion” (1936)8 and 3) “Mental suggestion of motor acts” (1937).

The main result of these investigations concerned the elucidation of the physical nature of the factor that transmits mental suggestion. The result proved unexpected even for the investigators themselves. Contrary to the electromagnetic theory, the most careful screening with metal of the mentally suggesting “inductor” or of the “percipient” receiving the mental suggestion did not in any degree impair the transmission of mental suggestion in all those cases in which it manifested itself distinctly without screening. This unforeseen result, which at first perplexed us, called into question the correctness of the electromagnetic theory of telepathic phenomena. 8During the Great Patriotic War and in the years following it our investigations of mental suggestion were naturally interrupted. They were also temporarily held back in the countries of Western Europe. The International Committee for Psychical Research broke up. The organizational centre of these investigations moved from Copenhagen to New York (Parapsychology Foundation INC, in existence since 1951). The scientific contact of Soviet scientists with foreign investigators of parapsychical phenomena was completely broken off. The author of these lines, and probably nobody else in the Soviet Union either, knew what had been done abroad in the study of mental suggestion since the end of the thirties, while foreign investigators were burning with the desire to learn whether anything was being done in this direction in our country. In 1956 I established a correspondence with René Warcollier, President of the Paris International Metapsychical Institute, from whom I received some information on the state of parapsychological research abroad.

In 1959 Gospolitizdat published in a large edition a booklet I had written, “Mysterious Phenomena of the Human Psyche” (Moscow, 1959). One of its chapters (“Does brain radio exist?”) is devoted to a brief account of the history and present state of the telepathic problem, mention of which had not appeared in the pages of the Soviet press for about twenty years. The publication of this booklet played its part: articles on “biological radio communication” appeared in the newspapers, among them a note by the engineer B. B. Kazhinsky;9 P. I. Gulyaev 10 included in one of his booklets a chapter “Electromagnetic radiation of the brain”, in which he gives the reader some data on telepathy.

At the end of 1959 and the beginning of 1960 R. L. Kheroumian, a staff member of the Paris Metapsychical Institute, sent me two articles from French popular-science journals.11 The articles describe in detail a sensational experiment in mental suggestion carried out in the summer of 1959 on board the American atomic submarine “Nautilus”.12 9This experiment showed — and therein lies its chief significance — that telepathic information can be transmitted without delay through a mass of sea water and the closed metal hull of a submarine, i.e. through media which greatly hamper radio communication. They completely absorb short radio waves and partly long ones, greatly attenuating them, whereas the factor, still unknown to us, that transmits mental suggestion passes through them easily. This result was obtained by the Americans a quarter of a century later than our above-mentioned experiments of the 30s and fully confirmed them. The advantage of the American experiment over our experiments consists only in the fact that in its design the telepathic influence overcame a great distance and more considerable obstacles (an enormous mass of sea water plus the metal hull of the submarine).

Such an unexpected confirmation by foreign investigators of our experiments of 25 years before induced me to acquaint wide circles of scientific workers with them (the first report was given on 21 April 1960 at the Leningrad conference devoted to Radio Day, in the House of Scientists).13 Our early investigations have lost none of their interest. Rather the contrary: with the passage of time their significance has increased. They have withstood the severest test — the test of time. I have had to repeat my report many times in Leningrad and Moscow, and each time it met with lively interest among the audience.

Are telepathic phenomena to be recognized as reliably established facts or not? One thing is evident: they can no longer be ignored; they must be studied. The investigation of mental suggestion is now being pursued all over the world. In the Soviet Union we must keep abreast of what has already been done and what is being done on this question abroad, and, more than that, we must have our own experience in this matter.

That is why Leningrad University considered it timely to organize in 1960, at the Physiological Institute of the Faculty of Biology, a special laboratory for the study of telepathic phenomena under the direction of the author of these lines, and to publish this little book.

In its content it consists of the reports, bound together into a single whole and edited anew, of investigations of the 20s and 30s 10which I carried out jointly with my colleagues — V. A. Poderni, V. N. Finne (Chapters IV and V), I. F. Tomashevsky, A. V. Dubrovsky, R. I. Skaryatin (Chapters III, V–IX) and G. Yu. Belitsky (Chapter IV).

In essence it is a monographic account of many years of experimental investigations of mental suggestion, carried out with the use of three basic methods of studying this phenomenon — the motor, the sensory and especially the hypnogenic method. Of foremost importance are the experiments testing the electromagnetic theory of mental suggestion with the use of screening with metal of the “inductor” (i.e. the one who suggests) or of the “percipient” (the one who receives the suggestion).

In each chapter the description of our own experiments is preceded by a brief survey of the investigations of other authors who previously applied the given method of studying mental suggestion. In order to link the past with the present, our own investigations of the 20s and 30s with the present state of the question, I considered it necessary to add to the account a concluding Chapter X. This will help the reader to assess correctly the Soviet works of the 20s and 30s, to see what was new and original in them, what retains its novelty even today, and what deserves to be repeated and continued at the present-day methodological and technical level.

Chapter I of this little book was written more than a quarter of a century ago. I have deliberately left it unchanged, believing that a comparison of its content with the concluding Chapter X will give the reader a clear idea of the progress made in the study of mental suggestion over the last 25 years. The reader will find a fuller historical survey of the origin and development of the theory of mental suggestion in my popular-science booklet “Suggestion at a Distance” (Gospolitizdat, Moscow, 1962).

Chapter III was written in its main part by a participant in our investigations, the engineer R. I. Skaryatin, as long ago as 1934. The radio-engineering apparatus designed at that time could now probably be replaced by newer and more perfect apparatus. However, for the purpose of carrying out analogous experiments this has not yet been done by anyone.

The appendices to the book contain some unpublished materials relating to investigations of mental suggestion in the USSR, as well as extracts from little-known Soviet and foreign literary sources which are of considerable interest for the history of the question.

I have repeatedly had occasion to hear the following statement from critics: “First give a final proof of the reality of mental suggestion, binding on each and every one, and only then study and describe its properties, its physical nature, etc.” It may be foreseen that the same objection will be raised in regard to this little book as well. The author cannot agree with such an 11objection: it would not speed up but delay the investigation of the question.

Granted that any one series of the experiments I have presented, taken separately, is insufficient to establish the fact of mental suggestion; yet all the series of experiments in their totality, especially the present-day quantitative experiments (see Chapter X), make the existence of mental suggestion highly probable. This is sufficient for us, without waiting for its recognition by each and every one, to conduct further investigations of this phenomenon as though its real existence had already been finally established.

For it is precisely in the course of such investigations that all those conditions may be found which are necessary and sufficient for the uninterrupted experimental production of the phenomena of mental suggestion. And this will be the best proof of their real existence. Something similar to this has happened more than once in the history of science. For example, the study of the properties and regularities of the physiological action of hormones and vitamins, and even their practical application, began long before these substances were isolated in pure form and synthesized artificially, i.e. established “finally”.

I consider it my pleasant duty to express here my warm gratitude to Corresponding Member of the Academy of Sciences of the USSR Professor Aleksandr Danilovich Aleksandrov for supporting the author in his investigations of mental suggestion and in the publication of this little book. I thank Professor P. V. Terentiev for his friendly help in the statistical processing of the numerical material, and D. V. Zambrzhitskaya and O. L. Petrovicheva for their participation in the work of preparing the text of the manuscript for the press. Nor can I fail to express my heartfelt gratitude to R. L. Kheroumian for sending me numerous foreign publications on questions of parapsychology.

L. L. Vasiliev

February 1961

Notes

  1. V. M. Bekhterev. On experiments on “mental” influence on the behaviour of animals (in Russian). Problems of the Study and Education of Personality, issue 2. Petrograd, 1920, pp. 230–265. ↩
  2. P. Flexor. Experiments in so-called mental suggestion to animals (in Russian). Ibid., p. 272; A. G. Ivanov-Smolensky. Experiments in mental influence on animals (in Russian). Ibid., p. 266. ↩
  3. Analogous experiments on dogs were carried out at the same time in Moscow, in the Durov Practical Laboratory of Zoopsychology, directed by V. L. Durov, with the participation of one of the pioneers of the investigation of mental suggestion in the USSR, the engineer B. B. Kazhinsky (see B. B. Kazhinsky. Transmission of Thoughts (in Russian). Moscow, 1923). ↩
  4. V. M. Bekhterev. Collective Reflexology (in Russian). Petrograd, 1921, p. 263. 5: The text of this point of the resolution is given in Appendix 1 at the end of this little book. ↩
  5. Otherwise “parapsychical” investigations. ↩
  6. See V. P. Osipov's preface to the laboratory's report for 1934 (Appendix 2). ↩
  7. See Appendix 3. ↩
  8. This report served I. F. Tomashevsky as his candidate's dissertation, which he defended in 1936 at the Brain Institute. ↩
  9. B. B. Kazhinsky. Radio transmission of thoughts (in Russian). Komsomolskaya Pravda, 15 Nov. 1959; M. Guzeeva. The psychology of tomorrow (in Russian). Leningradsky Universitet, 16 June 1960; Biological Radio Communication (a conversation with B. B. Kazhinsky) (in Russian). Nauka i Zhizn, 1960, No. 11, p. 46: Discussion: “Transmission of thoughts — is it possible?” (in Russian). Znanie—Sila, 1960, No. 12, pp. 18–23; Does the psi phenomenon exist? (A conversation with Prof. L. L. Vasiliev) (in Russian). Smena, 15 Jan. 1961; Discussion in the journal Tekhnika molodezhi, 1961, Nos. 1, 2, 3; V. P. Tugarinov. Once more on the transmission of thoughts (in Russian). Znanie—Sila, 1961, No. 7, p. 22. ↩
  10. P. I. Gulyaev. Electrical Processes of the Human Cerebral Cortex (in Russian). Leningrad University Press, 1960. ↩
  11. J. Bergier. La transmission de pensée — arme de guerre. «Constellation», 1959, n° 14, Decembre. G. Messadié. Du Nautilus. «Science et vie», 1960, n° 509, Fevrier. ↩
  12. The content of these articles should be treated with caution, since “authoritative persons in Washington state that they know nothing about any such experiment” (see Appendix 7). But it is also known that the leading parapsychological laboratory of the USA in 1952 received a money grant from the naval department (Offis of Naval Research) for investigations in the field of extrasensory perception (J. B. Rhine a. J. G. Pratt. Parapsychology (Frontier Science of the Mind). Springfield, 1957, p. 203). ↩
  13. L. L. Vasiliev. On electromagnetic radiations of the brain (in Russian). Abstracts of papers at the XV Scientific and Technical Conference dedicated to Radio Day. Leningrad, Publ. of the All-Union Radio Engineering Society, 1960. ↩