CHAPTER IX
SOME PSYCHOLOGICAL FEATURES OF MENTAL SUGGESTION
In the course of the investigation we encountered the following difficulty: how is it to be explained that in many experiments the mental suggestion of sleep or of waking is realized not immediately after the beginning of induction, but after some time — after 2–3 min or more? To settle this question we plotted the curves of distribution of variants generally accepted in variation statistics. Along the abscissa were marked, in minutes, the values of the speed with which mental putting to sleep (Fig. 28, A) or mental awakening (Fig. 28, B) was realized. Along the ordinate was marked the number of cases we observed of actual falling asleep or awakening realized at one speed or another. The subjects were Fedorova (F.), Ivanova (I.) and E. S. (S.).
The graphs given show clearly that in the greatest number of cases falling asleep and awakening set in before the first minute after the beginning of mental suggestion. In individual cases, however, the realization of the suggestion was drawn out to 10 minutes or more.
Other graphs (which we do not give here), constructed on the same principle, showed that such a delay of the telepathic effect is to some extent conditioned by the properties of the inductor, apparently by his ability to concentrate on the suggestion being transmitted. Thus, in the experiments conducted by the inductor Tomashevsky, a considerable majority of the cases both of putting to sleep and of awakening fell within short intervals of time (0.5–1.0). With Dubrovsky as inductor, the realization of putting to sleep and of awakening was, on the whole, spread over longer intervals of time.
The causes of this delay were to a considerable extent clarified when we began to use in our experiments the method of questioning the subjects in the form known under the name of “hypnoanalysis”. The procedure we used consisted in
138the observer who was with the mentally put to sleep subject putting a number of questions to her in order to find out her subjective experiences. For example: “Why did you fall asleep? Could you have not fallen asleep? Who put you into this state? What do you feel at this moment? What comes into your head?” and so on.

Fig. 28. Distribution curves of the durations of mental putting to sleep (A) and mental awakening (B) of three subjects: F., I. and S. On the abscissa — time in minutes; on the ordinate — the frequency of the variants marked on the abscissa.
In this way it proved possible to establish that the subjects showed a certain resistance, a kind of negativism, with respect to the realization of a mental suggestion already subconsciously perceived. By way of illustration we give the protocol of one of the characteristic experiments of this kind.
Experiment of 22 Apr. 1934. Subject Fedorova. Inductor Tomashevsky. Observer Dubrovsky. The subject arrived at the laboratory at 8 h 30 min and was laid on the couch in the Faraday cage at 8 h 55 min. With the subject in the same cage is the observer, who carries on a conversation with her; the door of the cage is open.
At 9 h 12 min the inductor, who is present in the same room but outside the subject's field of vision, begins mentally to suggest 139sleep. At 9 h 12 min 30 sec, after only 30 sec, the subject sinks into hypnosis and remains in this state for more than 2 h on end, being in rapport with the observer. At 11 h 39 min the inductor enters the total screening chamber, which is in the same room, and begins mental awakening. The observer thereupon records the following verbal statements of the subject: “Iosif Frantsevich (Tomashevsky. — L. V.) is speaking, waking me... Well, meanwhile wind the little ball, and I'll lie here a while... Sit, sit... Oh, how he shouts... What a little voice... Don't worry, I'll get up soon... You'll strain yourself... A pity... about your little throat... Enough, do you hear?... Tar... tar... Worse than bitter radish... Hang up the receiver... The little ball is wound up... Enough, I'm getting up.” At the last words, at 11 h 41 min, the subject awakens.
At 11 h 44 min the inductor proceeds to a second mental putting to sleep. The subject declares: “I. F. is quietly casting the little thread, he tells me to sleep... Enough... Hang up the little receiver...” A minute later, at 11 h 45 min, — hypnosis. At 11 h 50 min the inductor, remaining all the time in the total screening chamber, begins mental awakening. The subject immediately declares: “What's this... I'm fed up with him... He won't let me lie quietly... I. F. has an interesting face... he sits with his eyes closed and speaks... Too sharply... More carefully... Wind the little ball...” After the last words, at 11 h 54 min, waking sets in.
We have given the protocol of this typical experiment in order to lead the reader from the abstractions and figures of the preceding chapters into the concrete reality of our everyday observations. Experiments of this kind are filled with a mass of details deserving attention, on which we cannot dwell here. Let us note only certain features common to the majority of the experiments we conducted.
1. The impression is created as though the mental suggestion of sleep or of waking is perceived by the subject at once, but the realization of the suggestion already perceived is more or less postponed owing to the presence of a peculiar counteraction, of a conscious or subconscious character. Let us note that the same kind of resistance to the hypnotist's command is often observed with ordinary (verbal) suggestion as well.
2. Questioning shows that the subject subjectively perceives some kind of connection with the inductor, designating it symbolically now as a “thread”, now as an “unwinding little ball”, and so on; she often perceives the mental suggestion as a command transmitted to her by telephone. These details, of course, cannot give us an idea of the character of the energetic influence of the inductor on the percipient, but from the psychological side they deserve attention.
3. The same questioning gives grounds for supposing that the subject not only senses a peculiar connection with the inductor, but
140also recognizes which of the experimenters is acting on her by mental suggestion. In this respect one of the experiments is particularly indicative. We give in full the protocol records relating to it.
Experiment of 20 Apr. 1934. The subject Fedorova arrived at the laboratory at 9 h 30 min and, to rest before the experiment, was shown into room . At that time Prof. Vasiliev came into room , and Tomashevsky, who had until then been with the subject, joined him. In discussing the conditions of the forthcoming experiment the following plan was devised: the subject was to be placed in chamber No. 1, located in room ; Tomashevsky was to remain with her as observer; Vasiliev, who had never before put this subject to sleep, either mentally or verbally, would pretend to leave the laboratory; in reality, however, he would go over to the distant room in order to begin mental putting to sleep at a moment unknown to the observer (Tomashevsky).
The plan devised was carried out. At 9 h 55 min the subject was transferred from room to room and entered the chamber together with Tomashevsky. Vasiliev staged his departure from the laboratory and went over to the distant room . Throughout the experiment the observer questioned the subject, entering his questions and her answers in the protocol. At 9 h 58 min the inductor (Vasiliev) began the mental suggestion of sleep. At 10 h 00 min the subject sank into hypnosis.
Subj. No more, please...
Obs. Who put you to sleep?
Subj. You... Today it puts me to sleep well...
Obs. Who is putting you to sleep?
Subj. Tomashevsky.
Obs. And what else comes into your head?
Subj. Vasiliev keeps pushing into my head... As soon as I fell asleep I remembered him, and now he keeps pushing into my head...
At 10 h 18 min the idea occurred to the inductor (Vasiliev) to transmit to the subject the image of a bird, which he pictured to himself as a condor or a vulture. At approximately the same time the observer put the question to the subject: “Tell me, what comes into your head?”
Subj. He shows it well...
Obs. And who is he?
Subj. Vasiliev, his eyes are sticking out...
Immediately after this:
Subj. A cock... Now I see him. He is sitting at a table, a round one (the inductor was indeed sitting at a round table). It is he who has taken everything away from me...
Obs. And who put you into hypnosis?
Subj. So it was he who put me into it... He has bound me fast...
At 10 h 35 min the inductor goes over to the subject's room and enters the iron screening chamber No. 2 (see Fig. 18). 141At 10 h 40 min the inductor begins to awaken the subject mentally.
Subj. Sit there... He is winding up a ball of thread... That's enough... Professor Vasiliev, stop it... Well, I shall have to wake up... I don't feel like it... All right, that's enough...
At 10 h 41 min.
Subj. I'm tired of it... Vasiliev is there (points in the direction of the screening chamber), he is sitting there... How the poor man is straining himself... I can hear it, you know...
At 10 h 43 min the subject wakes up. At 10 h 43.5 min the inductor (contrary to his usual practice, immediately after the subject's awakening) begins a second suggestion of sleep.
Subj. Something is not right...
At 10 h 46 min she falls asleep.
The most essential thing in this experiment, as it seems to us, is not only that the subject recognized the inductor, although he, we repeat, had never once in two years of acquaintance with the subject tried to put her to sleep, but also that throughout the experiment the subject registered quite accurately the behaviour of the inductor and the place where he was.
These phenomena could be explained either by the percipient's ability to recognize the inductor by the character of the energetic influence received from him, or else by an ability to perceive the content of the subconscious sphere of the observer, who in this case, although he knew who the inductor was, what he was doing and where he was, was, being occupied with questioning the subject and compiling the protocol, far from consciously suggesting anything whatsoever to the subject. If the second supposition is correct, then we have in this case the phenomenon studied in detail by French authors under the name of “thought reading” (lecture des pensées, — E. Osty1 and others).
Thus we see that the “hypnogenic” method we have worked out is not only extremely suitable for conducting psychophysical experiments, but also makes it possible to penetrate more deeply into those psychological mechanisms on which the realization of mental suggestion depends, and knowledge of which is in any case indispensable for solving the question of the energetic nature of this phenomenon.
It remains for us to touch on one more question, comparatively little elucidated in the contemporary literature — the question of the so-called directedness of telepathic transmission. In posing it we came to the necessity of distinguishing directedness of three types:
1. Is it necessary for the success of a telepathic experiment that the inductor should know in what direction from him the percipient is located; is it necessary that the inductor should 142mentally direct his suggestion in this direction? This case we agreed to call the “geometric” directedness of suggestion.
2. Is it necessary that the inductor should know the physical environment (surroundings) in which the percipient is located during the experiment? Such directedness of suggestion we conventionally call “physical”.
3. Is it necessary that the inductor should know who the percipient is in the given experiment? Must the inductor associate the suggested image with the image of the percipient? This condition was called by us the “psychological” directedness of suggestion.
To clarify the significance of each of these types of directedness we set up special experiments, which led us to the following results.
“Geometric”, like “physical”, directedness of suggestion is apparently of no significance. A number of experiments conducted by us by the hypnogenic method clearly shows that the inductor may be entirely unaware of the direction from him and of the premises in which the percipient is located, and yet the act of mental putting to sleep or awakening is realized in the usual way. By way of illustration let us cite at least one of the experiments of this kind.
Experiment 5 Apr. 1934. The subject Fedorova arrived at the laboratory of the Brain Institute at 8 h 25 min in the evening; she was met by Tomashevsky and laid on the couch in the small room. It had been agreed beforehand that the inductor would be Dr. Kayalov, who during the experiment was in the building of the Psychotherapeutic Preventorium on Stachek Street, at a distance of approximately 7,700 m from the laboratory. The inductor did not know where the laboratory was situated and had never been in it; the inductor was not acquainted with the observer Tomashevsky, who was with the subject. The subject Fedorova was one of Dr. Kayalov's patients, and he was informed that it was she who would be the percipient in the given experiment.
The watches of the inductor and of the observer had been synchronized beforehand by telephone.
At 8 h 50 min Dr. Kayalov begins the mental putting to sleep. In the same minute (8 h 50 min) the subject declares: “I must write to Kayalov, but now I won’t write after all.”
At 9 h 00 min the subject: “I feel somehow calm, I don’t want to move, my face seems not to be mine.”
At 9 h 03 min: “I want to close my eyes.” She closes her eyes and at 9 h 04 min sinks into hypnosis.
At 9 h 30 min the inductor Kayalov begins the mental awakening.
At 9 h 40 min the subject declares: “I feel that I must open my eyes.” She opens her eyes and stares at one point, but at 9 h 44 min closes them again. 143At 9 h 45 min the subject again declares: “Strange, I want to wake up,” and at this she finally awakens.
But if “geometric” and “physical” directedness, as the experiment cited clearly shows, plays no essential role, then with regard to “psychological” directedness our experiments incline us to the opposite conclusion: the inductor must know who the percipient is in the given experiment, otherwise the mental suggestion remains unrealized. Of the considerable number of experiments set up in this direction we shall dwell on at least the following two:
Experiment of 14 Apr. 1934. The subject Ivanova arrived at the laboratory at 9 h in the evening. She went into the round room (Б) and settled in an armchair by the electric stove. At 9 h 30 min the second subject, Fedorova, arrived; she was placed on the couch in the small room (А). The observer with her was Tomashevsky.
At 10 h 30 min the inductor, Dr. Dubrovsky, entered the Faraday cage located in the round room, i.e., where the first subject, Ivanova, remained.
At 10 h 35 min the inductor begins the mental putting to sleep, directing the induction at the subject Fedorova.
At 11 h 00 min Fedorova sinks into hypnosis. In the subject Ivanova, at whom the induction was not directed, a drowsy state arose three times in the interval from 10 h 35 min to 11 h 00 min; it did not, however, pass into hypnosis and disappeared at once when the subject was addressed with a question.
At 11 h 30 min Ivanova was moved to the small room and seated in an armchair separated by a screen from Fedorova, who remained in hypnosis. With both subjects is the observer Tomashevsky.
At 11 h 33 min the inductor Dubrovsky, being in the round room, in the Faraday cage, begins mentally to suggest sleep to Ivanova.
At 11 h 39 min the suggestion is realized: Ivanova falls into the hypnotic state. Fedorova continues to sleep.
At 12 h 12 min the inductor, remaining all the time in the Faraday cage, begins the mental awakening of Fedorova.
At 12 h 25 min Fedorova declares: “He is waking me, but nothing comes of it, Arseny Vasilievich is straining himself” (the name and patronymic of the inductor). However, the inductor did not succeed in achieving the actual awakening of the subject. The further course of the experiment is of no interest, and we omit it. Still more expressive is the following experiment, recorded kymographically.
Experiment of 19 Apr. 1934. The subjects Fedorova and Ivanova were in different rooms of the laboratory, Fedorova being placed in the Faraday cage. Neither knew of the presence of the other. Fedorova’s state could be followed from the kymographic record, while Ivanova was observed by Dr. 144Dubrovsky. The inductor Tomashevsky was in the round room, i.e., in the same room where Fedorova was.
At 9 h 19 min the induction began, directed at the falling asleep of Fedorova. At 9 h 20 min sleep set in. At 10 h 35 min the inductor moved over to Fedorova in the Faraday cage. At 10 h 37 min the induction began, directed at the falling asleep of Ivanova. At 10 h 41 min sleep set in in her.
At 10 h 58 min the mental awakening of Ivanova was begun, and at 11 h she awoke. At the same time, despite the immediate proximity of the inductor (Tomashevsky), the subject Fedorova continued to remain asleep, showing no reaction whatever to the suggestion of awakening, which was directed not at her but at Ivanova.
Similar experiments with the participation of two subjects were conducted at three sessions with identical results. The reaction to mental suggestion was obtained precisely in that one of the subjects at whom the induction was directed.
For the purpose of further verification of these results, experiments were also conducted by the following method. The subject was put, as usual by mental suggestion, into hypnotic sleep. She remained in this state for some 20–30 min. At this time the inductor began the mental “awakening” of some absent person “X”, continuing to induce for 5 min. No awakening of the subject was observed in these experiments. After this the inductor began to act mentally on the subject. In four cases the percipient was within the inductor’s field of vision, and in three cases she was in another room. The results of these experiments are given in Table 18.
Table 18
Results of experiments on awakening the subject by directed and non-directed suggestion
| No. | Time of beginning of suggestion | Waking occurred after | Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 8 h 39 min | 0 min 05 sec | From another room |
| 2 | 8 48 | 1 15 | Within the inductor’s field of vision |
| 3 | 5 40 | 1 00 | ” |
| 4 | 7 20 | 0 30 | From another room |
| 5 | 8 10 | 0 45 | Within the inductor’s field of vision |
| 6 | 8 48 | 0 15 | ” |
| 7 | 11 20 | 2 10 | From another room |
As can be seen from the table, in 6 experiments with directed influence awakening occurred in less than 2 min, and only in one case did it take 2 min 10 sec. In the control experiments (suggestion to “X”) a 5-minute induction did not awaken the subjects. 145On the basis of the experiments cited and many others like them, we arrive at a conclusion which, from the psychophysical point of view, may seem somewhat unexpected and difficult to explain: psychological directedness is, apparently, a necessary condition for mental suggestion to be accomplished. The content of the suggestion being transmitted must be accompanied by a mental image of the person to whom the suggestion is being transmitted.
It should be noted that some of the earlier investigators of the telepathic phenomenon also arrived at the same conclusion. Thus, for example, Caslant wrote the following about the phenomena of telepathy: “In order to achieve the best result of induction, it is necessary to formulate mentally the task that one wishes to transmit, and then consciously to send it to the subject, picturing his image to oneself as vividly as possible.”2
Caslant regards this condition as a factor that improves the result of induction, but not as an obligatory one. Warcollier, as already mentioned in Chapter VIII, experimenting in 1923–1925 over the distance Paris–New York, became convinced that of 20 experiments in mental suggestion only 5 proved successful, and precisely with those of the American percipients whom the Parisian inductors knew. Noting this circumstance, Warcollier rejects chance in the results obtained, and explains the very fact of perception in this case by a “mental means” (contagion mentale).
Confirmation that in the absence of selective directedness there is no positive effect may be provided by the experiment of Lodge, organized by him to ascertain the possibility of telepathic transmission to persons unknown to the inductor. For this purpose he used a broadcasting radio station, from which listeners were asked to write down, at a definite hour and minute, whatever came into their heads. In three series of experiments out of five, the general character of the object being transmitted was announced; in the two remaining series this was not announced. About 25,000 replies were received, of which only very few were approximately correct. The result obtained did not exceed that which could be expected according to the theory of probability. An experiment of the same kind was organized by Gardner Murphy in Chicago on 3 March 1924. More than 2,000 replies were received, and none of them, Warcollier remarks, indicated the presence of telepathic transmission.
Thus, according to the data of our experiments, a rapport is established between the inductor and the percipient that is not one-sided but two-sided: on the one hand, the inductor must direct the induction precisely at the given percipient; on the other hand, 146the percipient recognizes from the telepatheme he perceives who is acting as inductor at the given moment.3
This result of ours finds support in the investigations of earlier authors. The London investigators of the phenomena of spontaneous telepathy long ago described cases in which the percipient telepathically perceived the experiences of the inductor, while the inductor at the same moment, and likewise telepathically, perceived the situation in which the percipient found himself at that moment. These very rare cases were called “reciprocal” (two-way) telepathy.
Something similar was observed in his experiments by the Moscow physicist S. Ya. Turlygin, a pupil of Academician P. P. Lazarev. In his work “Radiation of Microwaves ( mm) by the Human Organism” he writes: “The subject T. N. declared to us that she ‘feels’ perfectly well when the inductor is ‘working’,4 and can determine the moment of his working. To check this statement, we conducted experiments in the following manner. Having placed the hypnotist-inductor in the booth, whose nozzle (a tube in the front wall of the booth.— L. V.) was covered with cigarette paper, and having seated the subject on a chair at a distance of 2 m in front of the nozzle, we would begin the next experiment, continuing it until the subject’s first error. The conventional signal to the inductor — to work or not — was given by a noiselessly pulled thread. The beginning of the experiments usually went successfully; the subject quickly gave faultless answers as to whether the inductor was working or not working. But with the passage of time the answers, as a rule, gradually slowed down from fatigue. In the control experiment the last correct answer was given in the 35th minute. This was the 17th correct answer.
If we assume that the subject’s answers coincided by chance with the whole of our completely arbitrary alternation of the sequence of ‘working’ and ‘not working’, then the probability of such an event, with 17 uninterrupted correct answers, would be as follows:
i.e., such a case would be completely improbable: one positive chance against three and a half thousand million million negative chances.”5
Summing up everything set forth in the last three chapters, we arrive at the following basic facts and conclusions.
Firstly, we must conclude that in order to set up experiments for elucidating the psychophysical nature of the telepathic phenomenon, a preliminary selection of 147sensitive subjects must be made. This is necessary for obtaining sufficiently convincing results.
Secondly, we state that the “hypnogenic method” we have worked out, using the self-report of the person under investigation and objective recording of his reactions, is fully suitable for further experiments, since the results obtained with the aid of this method are distinct and unambiguous.
Thirdly, we can conclude that it is not obligatory for the experimenter to know the location of the person under investigation and the surroundings in which he finds himself. On the other hand, the experimenter apparently must know the person under investigation by sight and distinctly picture to himself his visual image in order for telepathic transmission to be accomplished.
Fourthly, it apparently has to be accepted that the distance between the experimenter and the person under investigation plays no appreciable role; but this does not mean that the inverse-square law is inapplicable in the given case.4
Fifthly, we note that so far no one has succeeded in establishing any physical indicator of the radiations that are produced by the brain and transmit the telepatheme. Cazzamalli's assertions and his experiments on recording electromagnetic waves of the human brain have not been confirmed by us.
And, finally, sixthly, we state that screening the experimenter from the person under investigation by metal does not, contrary to certain data available in the literature of the question, prevent the telepathic phenomenon from taking place. Hence it has to be concluded that if the transmission of thought at a distance is indeed accomplished by the radiation of electromagnetic energy from the central nervous system, then this electromagnetic energy must be sought in the region of kilometre electromagnetic waves or beyond the soft X-rays; but both the one and the other supposition are hardly probable.5
Such are our conclusions. As can be seen, the task of further research becomes more complicated, and from the purely psychological domain it passes into the domain of psychophysical experiment, which must either confirm the hypothesis of the electromagnetic nature of the energy transmitting the telepatheme or, having rejected this hypothesis, seek a still unknown kind of energy specific to that highest form of matter which the human brain is.6 148In February 1961 the author received an extremely important communication from the foremost hypnologist of our country, Professor Konstantin Ivanovich Platonov, author of the monograph “The Word as a Physiological and Therapeutic Factor”, which has been published three times in our country and translated into foreign languages.7
The materials sent by Prof. Platonov (see Appendices 5 and 6) attest that as early as 1924 a group of Kharkov scientists carried out an investigation, small in scope but very valuable in content, using the hypnogenic method of mental suggestion and with screening of the suggester from the subject of suggestion. This unpublished work represents, as it were, a reduced copy of our many years of research.
It is with great satisfaction that we can note that the results and conclusions outlined by the Kharkov investigators coincide in many respects with what was established by us ten years later. Such a coincidence is in itself highly significant.