L. L. Vasiliev

Experimental Studies of Mental Suggestion · pp. 113–128

CHAPTER VII

A CRITICAL APPRAISAL OF THE HYPNOGENIC METHOD AND OF THE RESULTS OF ITS APPLICATION. AN IMPROVED VARIANT OF THE HYPNOGENIC METHOD

First of all it must be noted that the hypnogenic method gave us more consistent positive results than the methods of mental suggestion described in the preceding chapters. As was already mentioned in the preceding chapter, out of 260 experiments mental putting to sleep failed in only 6 cases, and mental awakening in 21 cases.

To this it must be added that the failure of mental putting to sleep or awakening to be realized usually had definite causes, for example: a plainly excited state of the subject, the presence of outsiders, of persons little known to her, or the presence of some extraneous stimuli (unusual noises, constriction by clothing, etc.). After these interferences had been removed, the mental suggestion was in the majority of cases realized. In some cases mental awakening was not achieved, apparently because it was carried out by an inductor other than the one who had brought about the mental putting to sleep.

The hypnogenic method allows one to gain such mastery over the phenomenon of mental suggestion that we repeatedly ventured (and not without success) to demonstrate this phenomenon, which is, generally speaking, a very “capricious” one, to visitors admitted to the work.

However, in the systematic application of the hypnogenic method we encountered a phenomenon which could have been a serious source of possible errors. This phenomenon consists in the following. With frequently induced mental (as well as verbal) puttings to sleep and awakenings, the subjects develop a peculiar form of narcolepsy, or autohypnosis: the subjects begin to fall into the hypnotic state spontaneously (without mental suggestion to fall asleep) and likewise spontaneously come out of this state, which was not observed in the first experiments with the same subjects. Here we are, in all probability, dealing with a hypnogenic conditioned reflex 114developing with the repetition of experiments in the given setting. The setting of the experiment becomes a complex conditioned signal evoking sleep (see Chapter VI).

Such autohypnosis had already been noticed in the 1920s during the experiments in mental putting to sleep that Academician V. M. Bekhterev conducted together with me on Mikhailova, a subject of Prof. K. I. Platonov.

In all, in the experiments with our three subjects, we registered 9 cases of spontaneous falling asleep and 18 cases of similarly spontaneous awakening, which in relation to the total number of realized mental puttings to sleep and awakenings (260) amounts to 10.04%. As an illustration of such “hypnogenic automatism” we present a kymogram recorded in the experiment of 25 Jan. 1934 (percipient Fedorova, inductor Tomashevsky).

As can be seen from an examination of this kymogram (Fig. 20), at 9 h 33 min the subject stopped squeezing the rubber bulb and unexpectedly fell into the hypnotic state (autohypnosis). At 9 h 44 min she spontaneously awoke, as is indicated by the resumption of the oscillations of the curve. At 9 h 50 min the mental command to fall asleep was given (“З”), and 3 min later the subject fell asleep (“Г”, 9 h 53 min), but then, at 10 h 15 min, she again spontaneously passed into the waking state. A new mental command to fall asleep took effect at once, after which, at 10 h 37.5 min, the subject was mentally awakened.

Fig. 20. Recording of spontaneous falling asleep (autohypnosis) and awakening of subject K. G. Fedorova (plate 2)

Fig. 20. Registration of spontaneous falling asleep (autohypnosis) and awakening of the subject K. G. Fedorova. The notation is the same as in Fig. 15.

It was necessary to find some means of at least weakening this phenomenon. First of all we began to refrain from frequent and repeated mental puttings to sleep and awakenings in the course of one and the same session. Then we noticed that the subjects do not fall into autohypnosis provided that an observer is with them all the time, carrying on a conversation with them. Likewise, subjects already brought into the hypnotic state do not awaken spontaneously if verbal rapport is maintained with them.

It is remarkable that such diversion of the subjects' attention, while eliminating autohypnosis, in no way hinders the realization of the mental suggestion of sleep or wakefulness. This holds, however, on condition that the observer is a person well known to the subject; the presence of outsiders, of persons little known to her, acting as a strong additional stimulus, inhibits and not infrequently stops altogether the realization of mental suggestion. We noted cases when the subject, on receiving the mental command to fall asleep, fell asleep without finishing the sentence she was uttering, and only at the moment of the mentally induced awakening finished saying this sentence.

The measures indicated practically almost completely eliminated “hypnogenic automatism”, as we were able to convince ourselves by carrying out a series of control experiments. These experiments were conducted as follows. The subject remained under the very same con-

114 115ditions under which the experiments in mental putting to sleep were usually carried out (she lay on a couch, squeezed the rubber bulb, etc.). In spite of this the subject continued to remain in the waking state for an hour or more, answering questions occasionally put to her by the observer. But when at last the inductor (the same observer or someone else among the participants of the experiment) began the mental putting to sleep, the subject fell into hypnosis within 1–5 min. She could remain in the state of hypnosis for an hour or more, keeping rapport with the observer, and awoke as soon as 1–3 min after the inductor had sent the mental command to wake up.

Table 11 gives a general summary of such control experiments.

Table 11
Results of control experiments to determine the duration of the subjects' stay in the waking state and in the state of hypnosis induced by mental suggestion
No.SubjectsLocation of subjectsState of subjectsPeriod of observationDuration
BeginningEnd
1I. E. MSmall roomHypnosis9 h 31 min10 h 37 min1 h 06 min
2„„„11 1911 49.50 30.5
3„„„10 0211 07.51 5.5
4„„„10 4511 150 30
5„„Waking9 3510 060 31
6F. K. G.Faraday cage„10 3010 430 13
7„„Hypnosis9 5610 400 44
8„„Waking10 4010 590 19
9„„„9 4010 501 10
10„„Hypnosis10 5012 261 36
11„Small roomWaking10 2012 202 00
12„„Hypnosis9 0310 020 59
Fig. 21. Prevention of the onset of autohypnosis by maintaining verbal contact (plate 2)

Fig. 21. Prevention of the onset of autohypnosis by maintaining verbal contact between the subject K. G. F. and the observer. Control experiment. The kymogram is to be read from right to left and from bottom to top.

The kymogram of one of these experiments is given in Fig. 21. At 9 h 40 min the subject was laid on the couch in the Faraday cage and was asked, as usual, to squeeze the rubber bulb. The observer (Tomashevsky) was with the subject. He did not carry out any induction. As can be seen from the kymogram, the subject went on squeezing the bulb for a long time without falling into hypnosis. At 10 h 10 min the subject was given a rest of 15 min, after which the squeezing of the bulb was continued for another 20 min. Finally, at 10 h 45 min the inductor (Tomashevsky) began the mental putting to sleep. As can be seen from the kymogram, the subject's response immediately began to change in character: the excursions of the curve gradually decreased and the intervals between the excursions lengthened. Finally, 4 min 45 sec after the beginning of the mental 116suggestion the curve died away to nothing, and the subject sank into hypnosis.

A considerable part of the experiments included in the statistical analysis, whose results were given in the preceding chapter, was carried out under the conditions described, which weaken the manifestation of autohypnosis. But in subsequent experiments autohypnosis began to manifest itself again. It became necessary to look for new subjects suitable for experiments by the hypnogenic method, and such subjects were found. Among them were persons both of intellectual professions (a teacher, a translator, and others) and of manual labour. Among them were both healthy persons and neurotics.

With these subjects, by the same method and also under other experimental conditions described below, we began the second period of the work (1935–1936).

The first experiments in mental suggestion carried out on “fresh” subjects, who as yet knew nothing and expected nothing, are of particular value. Here are these first experiments on four new subjects:

Experiment 1. The subject Z. came to the laboratory for the first time to take part in an experiment. She did not know what the experiment was to consist of. Leaving her alone in the room, the experimenters withdrew to another room to confer about the proposed experiment. It was decided there and then to begin the mental putting to sleep of Z. immediately, without entering the room and without warning her of the beginning of the experiment. Observing the subject through a small window in the wall, the experimenters ascertained sleep 1 min 20 sec after the beginning of the suggestion and 3 min after the moment she had been left in the room.

Experiment 2. The subject I. came to the laboratory accompanied by Dr. Dubrovsky, went into room A and talked with him for 20 min. Of the presence in the laboratory of a second experimenter (the inductor) the subject was not

Fig. 19. Mental putting to sleep and mental awakening of subject A. I. K., who had come to the laboratory for the first time and had never before been subjected to experiments of this kind. Top—record of the squeezes of the bulb; bottom line—time marks in minutes; middle—line of the electromagnetic signal marker; its first drop—beginning of mental putting to sleep; second and third drops (with the letter „П“)—beginning of mental awakening.

Fig. 19. Mental putting to sleep and mental awakening of the subject A. I. K., who had come to the laboratory for the first time and had not previously been subjected to experiments of this kind. Top: record of the squeezings of the bulb; bottom line: time marks in minutes; middle: line of the electromagnetic signal marker; its first drop marks the beginning of the mental putting to sleep; the second and third drops (with the letter “П”) mark the beginning of the mental awakening. 117aware. 20 min after their arrival the inductor (Tomashevsky) began the mental suggestion of sleep from room B. After min from the beginning of the suggestion I.'s speech broke off and sleep set in.

Experiment 3. The subject B. came to the laboratory for the first time to take part in the experiments. At 6 h 10 min she was asked to sit quietly in an armchair and to squeeze a small rubber bulb of a pneumatic transmission (in room B). The squeezings of the bulb were recorded on the kymograph tape in another room (V), where the inductor was (see Fig. 22). At 6 h 21 min the inductor began the suggestion of sleep. Sleep set in after 30 sec. At 6 h 23 min 30 sec the inductor began the awakening, and at that very moment records indicating wakefulness were obtained.

Fig. 22. Plan of the laboratory with the new arrangement of the instruments. А — inductor's room (1 — lead chamber); Б — percipient's room (2 — Faraday cage); В — room for the recording instruments (3 — kymographic setup for recording the percipient's wakefulness, 4 — button for switching on the electromagnetic signal in the lead chamber for the inductor).

Fig. 22. Plan of the laboratory with the new arrangement of the apparatus. A — inductor's room (1 — lead chamber); B — percipient's room (2 — Faraday cage); V — room for the recording apparatus (3 — kymographic set-up for recording the percipient's wakefulness, 4 — button for switching on the electromagnetic signal for the inductor in the lead chamber).

Experiment 4. Subject K. came to the laboratory for the first time. The subject was asked to squeeze a small rubber bulb and to stop squeezing it if sleep set in. K. was left in room B, the inductor in room A (Fig. 22). The subject began squeezing the bulb at 8 h 20 min. At 8 h 22 min mental putting to sleep was begun, and after 4 min sleep set in. After 3 min the inductor made an attempt at mental suggestion to the subject to wake up (for the reaction to this suggestion see Fig. 19). At 8 h min the inductor for the second time began mental awa-

118kening, and after 1 min the first excursions appeared on the record, and after 2.5 min the subject woke up.

It should be noted that these experiments with the new subjects were already carried out with a different arrangement of the apparatus (as compared with Fig. 18). The recording apparatus was moved from the round room ББ to the side room ВВ (Fig. 22). The round room was now reserved for the percipients alone, while the inductor was placed in the most remote room АА. In this room a new “total screening” chamber (No. 3) with thicker walls was built, made of sheet lead 3 mm thick.1 The inductor entered the chamber through a hatch made in its “roof”, to which a wooden ladder led (Fig. 23). The distance between chambers 1 and 3 was 13 m. Rooms АА and ББ were separated by two intermediate rooms with three closed doors.

Fig. 23. External view of the lead chamber for screening the inductor. Above, the device for sealing the lid hermetically is shown schematically. 1 — lead-in from the recording room; 2 — electromagnetic coil; 3 — mercury.

Fig. 23. External view of the lead chamber for screening the inductor. Above, the device for hermetically sealing the lid is shown schematically. 1 — lead-in from the recording room; 2 — electromagnetic coil; 3 — mercury.

Subsequently, as the experiments on mental putting to sleep were repeated, conditioned-reflex falling asleep began to appear in the new subjects as well. This led us to work out a second variant of the hypnogenic method, in which conditioned-reflex falling asleep did not interfere with the conduct of the experiments. The essence of this new variant of the experiments was as follows.

The subject was left alone in the room and throughout the period of wakefulness squeezed the small bulb of the air transmission. In this variant of the experiments the Mitkevich roulette with two discs — white and black — was used again. The inductor withdrew from room ББ (see the plan of the laboratory), in which the person under investigation was, to room ВВ, started the kymograph and the roulette, at the same time marking the beginning of the experiment with a stop-watch. If the white disc came up on the roulette, the whole experiment proceeded without mental suggestion of sleep. 119The record on the kymograph was taken until the person under investigation fell into autohypnosis, and in some cases, perhaps, into natural sleep. The duration of the subject's wakefulness was determined by the stop-watch from the moment the experiment began until the record of the bulb squeezes on the kymograph ceased, i.e. until sleep set in.

If the black disc came up on the roulette, the inductor immediately began mental putting to sleep, suggesting sleep until the excursions of the curve on the kymograph ceased, which indicated the onset of sleep. Here too the time elapsed from the beginning of the experiment to the moment of onset of sleep was recorded by the stop-watch.

The methodological value of this variant of the experiments is as follows:

1. Throughout the whole experiment the person under investigation remains alone, left to himself. Thus he cannot receive any signals whatever from the inductor or the observer.

2. The inductor learns whether or not he is to suggest mental putting to sleep in the given session only after he has already left the subject's room and started the roulette.

3. Being in conditions conducive to sleep, the person under investigation sooner or later falls asleep or falls into autohypnosis. But if mental suggestion exists, then in the presence of mental suggestion of sleep the subject will fall asleep faster than in experiments carried out under the same conditions but without mental influence.2

Experiments using this method were carried out on four subjects in the evening hours, between 19 and 23 h, under electric lighting. In all, 53 experiments were carried out; of these, 27 experiments were without mental influence and 26 with mental suggestion of sleep. The persons investigated in these experiments were three women and one man (Z., I., B. and K.).

The results of the experiments are presented in Table 12, which gives the time from the beginning of the experiment to the onset of sleep. Since only a few experiments, and approximately the same number, were carried out with each of the four subjects, we considered it permissible on this occasion not to indicate which experiment numbers relate to which subjects.

As a result of statistical treatment of the experimental material the following data were obtained. Without mental suggestion of sleep the mean duration of falling asleep proved to be M1=17.7M_1 = 17.7 min, with a standard error of the mean of m1=±1.86m_1 = \pm 1.86 min. In the presence of mental influence the mean duration of fall-

Table 12 ##### Results of experiments on the hastening of the onset of autohypnosis in subjects during mental suggestion of sleep
Without suggestionWith suggestion
Experiment No.Time from the beginning of the experiment to the onset of sleepExperiment No.Time from the beginning of the experiment to the onset of sleep
15 min 00 sec16 min 00 sec
210 0025 40
311 0037 30
47 0047 10
516 0056 00
617 0067 10
76 0078 00
86 0084 45
95 0092 00
1018 10105 40
118 00116 00
1224 10126 20
1325 351312 10
1421 10148 15
1530 55154 30
1624 20167 15
1728 00178 05
1821 001812 55
1911 25194 25
2029 25203 10
2125 00214 30
2229 35228 00
2312 15237 50
2441 002412 08
2521 40255 10
2610 45267 00
2711 45
M1=17.7±1.86M_1 = 17.7 \pm 1.86 minM2=6.8±0.54M_2 = 6.8 \pm 0.54 min

asleep proved to be only M2=6.8M_2 = 6.8 min, with a standard error of the mean of m2=±0.54m_2 = \pm 0.54 min.

Thus, mental suggestion of sleep hastened falling asleep almost threefold. The question arises whether this difference can be considered reliable. To resolve this question we applied the formula for determining the coefficient of reliability of the difference:

t=M1−M2m12+m22>2.t = \dfrac{M_1 - M_2}{\sqrt{m_1^2 + m_2^2}} > 2.

Substituting the numerical data obtained in the experiments, we have

t=17.7−6.81.862+0.542=10.93.74=10.91.93=5.65, т. е. t≫2.t = \dfrac{17.7 - 6.8}{\sqrt{1.86^2 + 0.54^2}} = \dfrac{10.9}{\sqrt{3.74}} = \dfrac{10.9}{1.93} = 5.65, \text{ т. е. } t \gg 2.

121In the series of experiments presented, the coefficient proved to be equal to 5.65. Therefore the difference obtained with mental influence and without mental influence can be considered fully reliable. To make the results obtained more graphic, we present them in the form of a diagram (Fig. 24).

Under the same conditions a further 10 experiments were carried out with the subject N., 46 years old, perfectly healthy. The results are presented in Table 13.

Fig. 24. Diagrams of the experiments. А — time of falling asleep with hastening of falling asleep (autohypnosis) of the percipient by means of mental suggestion of sleep; Б — time of falling asleep of the same percipient without mental putting to sleep.

Fig. 24. Diagrams of the experiments. A — time of falling asleep with hastening of the falling asleep (autohypnosis) of the percipient by means of mental suggestion of sleep; B — time of falling asleep of the same percipient without mental putting to sleep.

Without mental influence, sleep set in on average after 6 min 50 sec. With mental influence, the onset of sleep occurred on average after 3 min 55 sec. As can be seen from these experiments, falling asleep in the presence of mental influence occurred in the subject N. considerably faster than without such influence.

Altogether we have at our disposal numerical data on the second variant of the hypnogenic method (with hastening of falling asleep), obtained in experiments on six subjects. The results for each of them are given in Table 14.

On the basis of these experiments we arrive at the following conclusion. When the subject has developed autohypnosis, or has an inclination to natural sleep, it proves possible, by means of

Table 13 ##### Results of experiments with the subject N. on the hastening of the onset of autohypnosis during mental suggestion of sleep
Experiment No.Time of beginning of the experimentTime from the beginning of the experiment to the onset of sleep
without suggestionwith suggestion
18 h 20 min—6 min 00 sec
28 105 min 00 sec—
38 107 10—
45 15—5 00
56 50—3 15
66 556 00—
77 25—3 30
88 278 15—
96 455 45—
107 30—1 50
M1=M_1 = 6 min 50 secM2=M_2 = 3 min 55 sec
Table 14 ##### Summary results of experiments on six subjects on the hastening of the onset of autohypnosis during mental suggestion of sleep
SubjectsNumber of experimentsMean time from the beginning of the experiment to the onset of sleep
without suggestionwith suggestion
F.1820 min 05 sec—
17—10 min 35 sec
Z.720 30—
7—7 29
A.826 40—
8—7 33
I.712 45—
6—6 30
K.56 12—
5—5 11
N.56 50—
5—3 55

mental suggestion of sleep, to hasten the process of falling asleep. This influence is exerted without the participation of any of the sense organs of the person under investigation. Consequently, it is exerted by way of mental suggestion.

The concluding series of experiments, with the most reliable possible screening of the inductor by lead, was carried out by the same method. In order to make the 123chamber impenetrable to electromagnetic waves, a trough was made along the edges of the hatch, and mercury was poured into it before each experiment. When the lead cover, suspended on a pulley, was lowered, its bent-down edges dipped 4.0 cm into the mercury (see Fig. 23). This arrangement fully ensured the absence of gaps between the cover and the chamber itself and thereby provided a more perfect screening of the interior of the chamber than in the iron chambers we had used earlier. Besides, lead, as is well known, stops the rays of the shortest wavelength (X-rays, gamma-rays). This would have been of importance if, contrary to expectation, it should turn out that precisely such rays are the factor transmitting mental suggestion at a distance from the brain of the inductor to the brain of the percipient.3

Inside the chamber were placed a chair for the inductor and a small shelf-table. The chamber could be lit by an electric bulb fed from an accumulator kept there. A coil with an iron core was fixed to the outer wall of the chamber; switching it on opened a contact device in the circuit of an electric signal lamp located inside the chamber.

A test of the screening properties of the chamber, made with a generator of decimetre electromagnetic waves (about 50 cm in length) and a corresponding radio receiver, showed convincingly that the chamber is completely impenetrable to these rays.

To determine the absorption of gamma-radiation by the walls of the chamber, measurements were made with a radium preparation. The measurements were made with a Hess electrometer, and the source of the rays was a radium preparation containing 19.3 mg of radium. On the basis of the data obtained it could be concluded that the lead chamber absorbs about 17% of the gamma-rays of radium.

The lead chamber stood in Room A. The percipient was placed at a distance of 13 m in an iron Faraday cage (Chamber No. 1) situated in the round room (Б) and separated from Room A by three walls (see the plan of the laboratory). From the iron chamber (No. 1) a tube was led into the recording room (В); it was connected with a Marey apparatus for recording on the kymograph tape the squeezing of a small rubber bulb held in the hand of the percipient, who lay on a couch. In the recording room there were a kymograph for recording the squeezes of the rubber bulb, an electromagnetic signal marker which made it possible to record the beginning of the mental putting to sleep, and a 124time marker which recorded time marks in minutes on the kymograph tape. In addition, the recording room had a stop-watch for measuring the time from the beginning of the experiment to the onset of sleep.

Both chambers were earthed by connecting their bodies to the water-supply system. Throughout this series of experiments the subject was Fedorova, our best percipient, who had also taken part in the previous experiments described in Chapter VI. The experiment itself was conducted as follows. Usually at about 8 o'clock in the evening the subject (Fedorova) came to the laboratory. Conversing with the experimenters, she rested for 20–25 min in Room Б. About 10 min before the beginning of the experiment the inductor (Tomashevsky) withdrew to Room A, where the lead chamber was installed, taking with him one of three envelopes, into each of which another participant in the experiments had previously put a note containing one of the following tasks: either to suggest from the lead chamber, or not to suggest at all, or to suggest from the same Room A while remaining outside the chamber. The percipient was left with the second participant in the experiment, who observed its course.

The percipient entered the iron chamber, lay down on the couch, took the small rubber bulb and received the following instruction from the observer: “Squeeze the rubber bulb as rhythmically as possible during the whole time you are awake; stop squeezing when drowsiness or sleep sets in; on awakening, begin squeezing again.” After this the observer tightly closed the door of the chamber and, going to the recording room В, shut two more doors behind him. The percipient's chamber was not lit; complete darkness reigned in it. This favoured the onset of autohypnosis.4

On entering the recording room В, the observer set the kymograph going, started the stop-watch, gave the inductor, by pressing a button, a light signal that all was ready for the experiment, and then noted the time at which the experiment began.

When the observer went over to the recording room, the inductor lowered himself through the hatch into the lead chamber, closed the lid of the hatch, switching on the lamp fed by the accumulator in the chamber, and opened the envelope with the task.

If the task was “to suggest from the chamber”, the inductor waited for the signal that all was ready for the experiment, and on receiving it immediately began the mental suggestion of sleep. On receiving the signal that sleep had set in, the inductor opened the hatch, came out of the chamber and showed the observer the task that had been in the envelope. This 125was done for mutual control and for the proper entry in the record of the experiment.

If the note drawn read “Suggest from the room”, the inductor opened the hatch and, on receiving the signal that the percipient was ready for the experiment, began to suggest sleep to her with the hatch open, standing on the seat of the chair in the chamber, so that his head projected out of the hatch. When he found the note “Do not suggest”, the inductor opened the hatch but refrained from any mental suggestion whatever and waited for the signal about the percipient's state.

In all the cases indicated the following conditions of the experiment were observed:

1. Until the end of the experiment the experimenter in Room BB did not know what the task of the given experiment was, remaining merely an observer-recorder.

2. The inductor opened the envelope with the task only when he was already in the closed lead chamber.

3. The subject was left to herself under conditions identical in all the experiments.

A summary of the results obtained under the conditions of the experiments described is presented in Table 15.

Table 15
Results of experiments on hastening the onset of autohypnosis by mental suggestion of sleep with the inductor screened
Group 1, without mental suggestionGroup 2, with mental suggestion from the chamberGroup 3, with mental suggestion outside the chamber
Experiment No.Time from the beginning of the experiment to the onset of sleepExperiment No.Time from the beginning of the experiment to the onset of sleepExperiment No.Time from the beginning of the experiment to the onset of sleep
17 min 10 sec15 min 10 sec13 min 50 sec
24 1521 2522 15
34 2033 40310 00
48 1043 4044 00
56 1053 5554 30
614 2063 2063 50
76 0574 1571 05
86 1083 05
97 10911 00
106 50107 35
1114 00
124 05
M1=7.40±0.98M_1 = 7.40 \pm 0.98 minM2=4.71±0.86M_2 = 4.71 \pm 0.86 minM3=4.21±1.06M_3 = 4.21 \pm 1.06 min
σ=3.39±0.69\sigma = 3.39 \pm 0.69σ=2.71±0.60\sigma = 2.71 \pm 0.60σ=2.82±0.75\sigma = 2.82 \pm 0.75

In the course of time the lead wall of the trough underwent a process of dissolution, and the mercury began to seep into the chamber. Therefore, in the last two experiments with screening

Fig. 25. Kymogram of a single sleep experiment conducted on one and the same percipient without mental suggestion (top) and with mental suggestion. С — sleep; Г — hypnosis.

Fig. 25. Kymogram of an individual sleep experiment carried out on one and the same percipient without mental suggestion (above) and with mental suggestion. С — sleep; Г — hypnosis. 127it became necessary to replace the mercury with fine lead filings, into which the lid of the hatch was lowered.

Fig. 25 shows, by way of example, two kymographic records of experiments of this series.

Processing of the numerical material obtained in 29 experiments yields the following: 12 experiments were performed without mental influence, and the time of onset of sleep from the beginning of the experiment proved to be on average M1=7.4M_1 = 7.4 min. With mental influence exerted from the lead screening chamber, the mean duration of falling asleep in 10 experiments proved to be M2=4.71M_2 = 4.71 min. With mental influence without screening of the inductor, the mean duration of falling asleep in the 7 experiments performed was only M3=4.21M_3 = 4.21 min.

Table 16
Comparison of the results of experiments on hastening the onset of autohypnosis by mental suggestion with screening
Groups of experimentsttPP
1st and 2nd2.070.02–0.05
1st and 3rd2.220.02–0.05
2nd and 3rd0.370.7–0.8

A comparison of the arithmetic means of the time of onset of sleep without mental suggestion (1st group of experiments) with that under mental suggestion from the chamber (2nd group) and under mental suggestion outside the chamber (3rd group) is presented in Table 16.

Hence the difference between the onset of sleep with suggestion and without suggestion has been proved, and screening of the inductor by the chamber has no effect on mental suggestion.

Fig. 26. Diagram of experiments with hastening of falling asleep (autohypnosis) of the percipient by means of mental suggestion of sleep.

Fig. 26. Diagram of the experiments on hastening the falling asleep (autohypnosis) of the percipient by means of mental suggestion of sleep. А — time of falling asleep of the percipient with mental suggestion and screening; Б — the same, without screening; В — time of falling asleep of the percipient without mental putting to sleep.

In Fig. 26 we present the results of this series of experiments in the form of a diagram. In six experiments with lead screening, mental suggestion was also applied for the awakening 128of the subject, and in these cases awakening ensued on average after only 1 min 25 sec.

Thus we have once again obtained data confirming the results of the preceding experiments with iron screening. Screening with iron or with lead, in the form in which we carried it out, does not hinder the propagation of the supposed waves or radiations transmitting mental suggestion.

Notes

  1. The thickness of the walls of our iron chambers was about 1 mm (see Ch. II). ↩
  2. In essence this method is analogous to the one later applied by S. Ya. Turlygin: in his experiments, too, he did not evoke but only hastened by mental suggestion a previously established reaction — the subjects' falling backwards (Ch. IV). ↩
  3. Metre, centimetre and millimetre waves were completely absorbed by the iron chambers and the lead chamber. As regards the retention of long (kilometre) waves, in this respect the lead chamber, despite the fact that its walls are three times thicker, hardly surpassed the iron chambers by much. This is due to the fact that iron absorbs long waves more than lead does. ↩
  4. That this was autohypnosis and not ordinary sleep was evident from the fact that the sleeping subject retained verbal rapport with the inductor Tomashevsky when, on receiving the signal that the subject had fallen asleep, he entered the chamber and put questions to her. ↩