L. L. Vasiliev

Experimental Studies of Mental Suggestion · pp. 179–197

APPENDICES

FROM AN ARTICLE ON THE FIRST ALL-RUSSIAN CONGRESS ON PSYCHONEUROLOGY, HELD IN MOSCOW IN JANUARY 1923 (“IZVESTIYA”, 1923, 16 JANUARY, NO. 10)

On the Direct Transmission of Thoughts

At the session of the psychological section on 15 January an extremely interesting question was raised, that of the possibility of the direct transmission of thought at a distance, which, in connection with the theory of Academician P. P. Lazarev explaining the nervous process by the appearance of ions, acquires the possibility of a natural-scientific explanation. A member of the congress, K. Sotonin, delivered a paper “On the Supposedly Direct Transmission of Thoughts in the Experiments of Academician V. M. Bekhterev”. Sotonin considers the direct transmission of thoughts improbable and holds that the existing facts of transmission can be explained by barely perceptible signs: movements of the eyes or of the trunk, even if unconscious. Academician V. M. Bekhterev, in his reply, pointed out that there is an enormous number of facts and observations of the direct transmission of thoughts and that this question cannot be rejected merely because it seems improbable. Flying through the air once seemed improbable, and in the field of mental phenomena so did hypnosis. Yet hypnosis is already applied in medicine, and people fly through the air. The solution of the question of the direct transmission of thoughts is, in the words of Academician V. M. Bekhterev, one of the urgent questions of the 20th century. In the experiments conducted by him, the transmission of thoughts was carried out not only on people but also on dogs. Moreover, the experiments were arranged in such a way that the possibility of hidden hints, prompting, etc., was eliminated. For example, the experimenter was placed in a closed booth, or the objects that had to be found were placed in another room. Similar experiments were carried out in Moscow on Durov's dogs, and they too were very successful. In the discussion that followed, Prof. Kozhevnikov1 spoke, likewise establishing facts of the direct transmission of thoughts.

180Prof. G. I. Chelpanov, while not denying the facts, does not, however, agree with their explanation by P. P. Lazarev's theory. In view of the importance of this question, Prof. G. I. Chelpanov put forward the proposal that at the next congress a special paper by V. M. Bekhterev should be devoted to it.

FROM THE RESOLUTION OF THE SECOND ALL-RUSSIAN CONGRESS ON PSYCHONEUROLOGY, APPROVED ON 10 JANUARY 1924 IN PETROGRAD (FROM ARCHIVAL MATERIALS)

The Section of Hypnosis, Suggestion and Psychotherapy of the Second All-Russian Congress on Psychoneurology, having heard a number of papers on mental suggestion, deems it necessary to adopt the following resolution: attaching great importance to the question of so-called mental suggestion, the Commission (elected to draw up the draft resolution. — L. V.) considers it highly desirable that this phenomenon be studied on strictly objective scientific principles, and also that there be participation in the activity of the International Committee created for the investigation of phenomena of this kind, and that a scientific research body with an appropriately equipped laboratory be organized under the Russian Committee.

Appendix 2

PREFACE BY PROF. V. P. OSIPOV TO THE REPORT FOR 1933–1934 OF THE SPECIAL LABORATORY FOR THE STUDY OF MENTAL SUGGESTION AT THE LENINGRAD BRAIN INSTITUTE (FROM ARCHIVAL MATERIALS)

The work carried out by a group of staff members of the Bekhterev Brain Institute on the theme “Psychophysical Investigations of the Telepathic Phenomenon” is very considerable; it has demanded a great exertion of strength and energy owing to the complex nature of the question and to the extreme difficulty of resolving it in either the positive or the negative direction.

Although very many years have passed since the question of telepathy was first posed, it nevertheless cannot be considered resolved, since the abundant material accumulated is far from free of objections. To resolve the question it is necessary to have scientifically studied experimental material proving the existence of a regular connection between the phenomena. Equally, a negative resolution of the question must also be rigorously argued.

In its investigations the group of workers of the Brain Institute has still by no means resolved the question in either direction; the successful experiments are lessened in their persuasiveness by a number of unsuccessful ones, although the statistical conclusions do seem to speak in the positive direction. It has emerged, moreover, that in order to 181elucidate the regular connection of the positive results it is necessary to assume a new kind of radiant energy, as yet unknown, which also contradicts the positive results of the investigation.

On the other hand, it would hardly be correct to regard the statistical preponderance of the positive data as fortuitous.

If the question is ultimately resolved in the negative, then this negative resolution too must be rigorously substantiated.

On studying the research material obtained, one must draw the unconditional conclusion that the investigations conducted at the Brain Institute have been set up in a fully scientific manner, and that a strict method of investigation has been worked out with a proper critical approach. It is necessary, however, for the further resolution of the question, to do a good deal more work, and to do it very thoroughly.

Director of the Brain Institute Prof. V. P. Osipov

1934 г.

Appendix 3

ON THE QUESTION OF TELEPATHIC PHENOMENA

Proposals of Academician V. F. Mitkevich, consultant physicist (from archival materials)

Concerning the psychophysical investigations of the telepathic phenomenon, I hold the following:

1. The numerous experiments carried out to date in which the percipient was put into a hypnotic state and awakened from it by a mental command, in both cases on the part of the inductor, must with full justification be recognized as sufficiently convincing proof of the objective reality of telepathic phenomena,2 even despite the fact that sometimes, in individual particular cases, spontaneous falling asleep and awakening of the percipient is conceivable.

2. In view of the possibility of a subconscious “collusion” between the inductor and the percipient (directly or through the mediation of third persons), the simple method of investigating the telepathic phenomenon indicated in point 1 cannot be considered in any degree reliable when conducting experiments aimed at elucidating the nature of the physical agent responsible for the telepathic connection, namely experiments concerning questions of screening, directed action, the influence of distance, etc.

3. The most reliable and expedient method might prove to be a complex method, the implementation of which I envisage as follows: 182a) By a mental command of the inductor the percipient is put into a hypnotic state.

b) The inductor then sets in motion a primitive roulette which, without the participation of the inductor's will, selects one of a group of equiprobable events (for example, the appearance before the inductor's eyes of a black or a white screen).

c) On the basis of the indication of the roulette the inductor mentally commands the percipient to guess the given event (for example, to guess “black” or “white”).

d) This process of telepathic transmission of a certain visual impression (for example, “black” or “white”) from the inductor to the percipient must be repeated in succession as many times as, on the basis of preliminary experiments and the theory of probability, will be required for the fact of the transmission of the inductor's random impressions to the percipient to be recognized as established.

e) To avoid interference in the form of subconscious suggestions on the part of the assistant who stays with the percipient put into the hypnotic state, measures must be taken so that the assistant's attention cannot become concentrated on any one of the equiprobable events. For example, in the case of “black” and “white” it is expedient to place before the assistant's eyes a continuously moving screen with alternating black and white parts of its surface.

24 May 1934

Appendix 4

ON THE FIRST EXPERIMENTS OF FRENCH PHYSICIANS IN HYPNOTIZATION AND AWAKENING AT A DISTANCE

As far as is known, the first experiments of this kind were carried out by the French physician Dusart as early as 1869. Many times he mentally put to sleep and awakened his patient, a young girl who was a somnambulist, when she did not at all expect it. The mental suggestion was made at different hours and always attained its aim. A description of some of Dusart's experiments is given in the well-known book of Dr. Ochorowicz.3 Here is one of them as described by Dusart himself.

From the first of January I discontinued my visits to the patient J. and broke off all relations with her family. I had no news whatever of my patient. But one day, on 12 January, when I was making my medical rounds at the other end of the town, at a distance of some ten kilometers from the patient, the thought occurred to me: what if, in spite of the distance, the cessation of all relations and the intervention of a third person (the patient's father was now himself magnetizing his daughter in my place), I could still 183make the patient obey me? I mentally forbade the patient to yield to her father's sleep-inducing influence; but half an hour later it occurred to me that if, contrary to expectation, my command were carried out, I would thereby do harm to the sick girl. I decided to lift the prohibition and stopped thinking about it. What then was my astonishment when on the following day a messenger came to me with a letter from the father of the patient J. The letter said that the day before, on the 12th, at 10 o'clock in the morning, he had succeeded in putting his daughter to sleep only after a long and very painful struggle. The patient, when she had been put to sleep, declared that she had resisted on my orders and had fallen asleep only when I had permitted her to do so.

This experiment is unlike the others: here there is neither putting to sleep nor awakening, but a mental suggestion of the impossibility of falling asleep — of sleeplessness. Another French physician, Héricourt, a collaborator of Prof. Janet, in 1878 induced at a distance hypnotic sleep in a hysterical patient 24 years of age, and by a mental command made her leave her apartment, go down into the street and walk along it to a definite place. These initial experiments did not attract sufficient attention, but they prepared the ground for the well-known experiments of Janet and Gibert, and later of Charles Richet, with the subject Léonie B. We have already mentioned these experiments in Chapter VI. In 1886 a most active member of the Society for Psychical Research, Frederic Myers, and the well-known Polish parapsychologist, professor of psychology at the University of Lvov, Julian Ochorowicz, came to Le Havre to take part in these experiments. Both of them published detailed descriptions of their observations. Prof. Ochorowicz writes of Léonie B.:4

This subject is a simple peasant woman, a Breton, about fifty years old, robust, honest, shy, not unintelligent, although she has received no education whatever (she could not even write, although she could make out letters after a fashion). She is of strong, sturdy build; in her youth she was hysterical, but she was cured. She has a husband and children, who enjoy excellent health. She is very easily put to sleep: one need only hold her hand, pressing it lightly, with the intention of putting her to sleep. After 2 to 5 min her gaze becomes dim, her eyelids begin to tremble with a fine tremor, until at last the eyeball hides beneath the lid. At the same time the chest heaves heavily; a state of malaise evidently takes possession of the subject. She utters a sigh and leans back, plunged into a deep sleep. (There follows a description of one of the experiments. — L. V.)

I found Drs. Gibert and Janet so firmly convinced of the indubitability of action at a distance that they readily submitted to all the conditions I set them and allowed me to verify the phenomena by every possible means. Dr. F. Myers, Marillier of the Psychological Society, another physician (A. T. Myers) and I formed a kind of commission, and all the details of the experiment were established by us jointly. Here are the precautions we observed in the experiments: 1841) The hour for the action at a distance was determined by drawing lots.

2) We communicated the hour to Gibert only a few minutes before the appointed time, and the members of the commission at once set off for the pavilion where the subject lived.

3) Neither she nor the other inhabitants of the pavilion, which stood one kilometre from our lodgings, had any idea either of the hour or of what kind of experiment would be carried out.

To avoid involuntary suggestion, the members of the commission entered the pavilion only in order to check whether sleep had set in. It was decided to repeat Héricourt's experiment: to put the subject to sleep (by mental suggestion. — L. V.) and make her come to them across the whole town.

It was half past eight in the evening. Gibert agreed to these conditions. The hour was fixed by lot. The mental action was to begin at 8 h 55 min and continue until 9 h 10 min. At that time there was no one in the pavilion except Léonie B. and the cook, who expected no attempt on our part. No one entered the pavilion. We approached the pavilion only after 9 h. Silence. The street was deserted. Without making the slightest noise, we divided into two groups in order to watch the house from a distance.

At 9 h 25 min I saw a shadow appear at the garden gate. It was she. I squeezed into a corner so as to listen without being noticed.

But it turned out that there was nothing to listen to: the somnambulist, after standing for a little while at the gate, went back into the garden (at that moment Gibert ceased to act upon her: from the strain of thought he had fallen into a kind of swoon or doze, which lasted until 9 h 35 min).

At 9 h 30 min the somnambulist again appears at the gate and this time rushes straight out into the street, without hesitating, with the haste of a person who is late and absolutely must do something important. The members of the commission who were on the road did not manage to warn us — myself and Dr. Myers. But on hearing hurried footsteps, we followed the somnambulist, who saw nothing around her or, at any rate, did not recognize us.

On reaching the rue Bar, she staggered, stopped and almost fell. Suddenly she again began to walk quickly. It was 9 h 35 min. (At that moment Gibert, having come to himself, began to act upon her again.) The somnambulist walked fast, paying no attention to anything.

Ten minutes later we came up to Gibert's house just as he, thinking that the experiment had failed and surprised that we had not yet returned, came out to meet us and ran into the somnambulist, whose eyes were still closed.

She does not recognize him. Absorbed in her hypnotic monomania, she rushes to the staircase, and we all follow her. Gibert wants 185to go into his study, but I take him by the arm and lead him into another room.

The somnambulist, greatly agitated, searches for him everywhere, bumps into us, feels nothing, runs into the study, repeating in a distressed tone: “Where is he? Where is M. Gibert?”

Meanwhile the magnetizer sits bent forward, without the slightest movement. She comes into the room, almost brushes against him in passing, but her excitement prevents her from recognizing him. Once more she rushes off into the other rooms. Then it occurs to Gibert to call her to him mentally, and as a result of this effort of will, or simply by coincidence, she comes back and seizes him by the hands.

She is overcome by wild joy. Like a child, she claps her hands, exclaiming: “Here you are! At last! Oh, how glad I am!”

I became convinced at last, — adds Dr. Ochorowicz, — of the remarkable phenomenon of psychical action at a distance, which brings about a complete revolution in the opinions and notions established hitherto.

“The agreement of separate observations with one another is for us the best criterion of truth,” wrote the well-known psychologist A. Binet in his article “Experimental Psychology at the London Congress of 1892”.5

Following this wise remark, I give a second description of the very same experiment in Le Havre, written by another of its participants — F. Myers.

The subject in these experiments with telepathic hypnotization was B., the well-known subject of Professor Pierre Janet. The experiments were conducted in Le Havre by Prof. Janet and the attending physician Dr. Gibert.

I give here extracts from my own experiments of 20–24 April 1886, carried out together with Dr. A. T. Myers, recorded in the form of protocols and forming the basis of an article in the journal of the Society of Physiological Psychology of 24 May (published also in the Proceedings of the Society for Psychical Research, vol. IV, London, pp. 131–137).

On the evening of 22 April we all dined at Dr. Gibert's; after dinner Gibert made another attempt to put the subject B. to sleep at a distance from his house in the rue Séry and to summon her to him by an effort of will. The subject was in the pavilion in the rue de la Ferme. At 8 h 55 min Gibert withdrew to his study, while Ochorowicz, Marillier, Janet and Myers went to the pavilion and waited in the street by the house. At 9 h 22 min Dr. Myers noticed the subject B., who appeared at the garden gate and disappeared again. Those who were watching her from a closer distance saw that she was clearly in a somnambulistic state, wandering about the garden and muttering something. At 9 h 25 min she came out (her eyes were closed the whole time, as far as could be seen), passed quickly by Janet and Marillier without noticing them, and set off towards Gibert's house by neither the usual nor the shortest route. (It later turned out 186that the cook had seen her go into the drawing-room at 8 h 45 min and come out of it asleep at 9 h 15 min, and she did not go in there again.) She went round lamp-posts and traffic and crossed the streets repeatedly. No one approached her or spoke to her. After 8–10 min her gait became more uncertain, she stopped, and it seemed that she would fall. Myers noted the time in the rue Fort: it was 9 h 35 min. At about 9 h 40 min she became bolder and at 9 h 45 min reached the street in which Gibert lived. There she met him, but paid no attention to him and went into his house, where she began to run from room to room on the ground floor. Gibert did not touch her hand until she recognized him. Then she calmed down. Gibert said that from 8 h 55 min to 9 h 20 min he had thought of her intensely, and from 9 h 20 min to 9 h 35 min he had thought of her less intently; at 9 h 35 min he had stopped the experiment and begun to play billiards, but after a few minutes he began again to call the subject. It turned out that his time in the billiard room coincided with the subject's state of indecision in the street, but this coincidence could have been accidental. . .

Out of a series of 25 such experiments, 19 were successful. The experiments were carried out at different times of day and at different intervals, so as to exclude the possibility of the subject expecting the experiment to begin.6

A comparison of the protocol records of Ochorowicz and Myers given above shows that these records largely coincide with each other and complement each other in their details. The hours and minutes noted in the protocols do not always coincide exactly; sometimes they differ by as much as 5 min (it is not stated whether Ochorowicz's and Myers's watches were synchronized before the experiment).

I may cite one more of Charles Richet's observations, made by him at Beaujon Hospital, apparently on a different subject.

Sitting one day with his colleagues at breakfast in the hospital's common dining-room (his colleague Landouzy, who was at that time also an intern at Beaujon Hospital, was present as well), Richet declared that he would undertake to put a certain patient to sleep at a distance and to make her come to the dining-room solely by the action of his will. When ten minutes had passed no one had come, and the experiment was considered a failure. In reality, however, matters turned out otherwise: a few minutes later someone came to say that the patient was wandering about the corridors asleep, looking for Dr. Richet and unable to find him.5

In the experiments with Léonie B., Richet's results were poorer than those of Janet and Gibert (only 16 successes out of 36 experiments, as against 19 successes out of 25 experiments for Janet and Gibert). Moreover, in Richet's experiments the mental putting to sleep of Léonie took effect with a delay of up to 11 min. In the experiments of Gibert and Janet the first signs of falling asleep were noticed as early as 2–5 min, depending on who was putting her to sleep —

187Gibert or Janet.7 In our experiments the subjects Fedorova and Ivanova in most cases fell asleep after 1–2 min (see Fig. 28), somewhat more quickly with Tomashevsky as inductor than with Dubrovsky as inductor.

Appendix 5

ON THE QUESTION OF TELEPATHY8

(The first attempt at a public demonstration of mental putting to sleep and awakening in the USSR)

Prof. K. I. Platonov

In connection with the debate on telepathy held in Kharkov (February 1961), my memories were revived of an experiment that I demonstrated at the All-Russian Congress of Psychoneurologists, Psychologists and Educators (Leningrad, December 1924).

At that Congress I confined myself to a demonstration alone, without any attempt to explain the essence of this enigmatic phenomenon, since it lay beyond the bounds of our knowledge at that time.

My experiment was conducted according to a definite method both before the large audience of the hypnology section of the Congress and in the laboratory of Leningrad University, with the participation in the experiment of the chairman of the Congress, V. M. Bekhterev, who had taken an interest in my demonstration.9

Among the members of the Congress present at the experiment were L. L. Vasiliev, E. S. Katkov, V. A. Poderni and others.

In the hall where the sessions of the hypnology section of the Congress were held, the experiment was conducted under the following conditions. The chairman of the section, Prof. A. V. Gerver, sat at the chairman's table, facing the audience. The subject M. sat at the same table, facing Professor G., who was conversing with her, and side-on to the audience. Behind her back, at a distance of some six metres, stood a blackboard, placed at an angle to the audience. I stood behind the blackboard, within the field of view of the audience and out of sight of the subject. Even before M. came into the hall it had been agreed with the audience that my silently covering my face with my hands would serve as the signal for the beginning of the experiment 188of putting her to sleep. Having covered my face, I mentally pictured to myself the figure of the subject M. fallen asleep during her conversation with Professor G., concentrating my strained attention on this for one minute. The effect was complete: M. fell asleep within a few seconds. The awakening was produced in the same way. This was repeated several times.

During the experiments in the laboratory I, as inductor, was in a closed booth with a small electric signal lamp (from a pocket torch). The button closing the circuit of this lamp was outside the booth, under the top of a table standing at its edge. V. M. Bekhterev, who gave me light signals with this lamp, sat with his back to the button, on which his fingers rested (behind his back). Opposite Bekhterev sat the subject M., who was receiving my mental influences. The signals were given to me by Bekhterev during his conversation with the subject M., and they were irregular, i.e. they were given at arbitrary moments.

On receiving the signal, I closed my eyes and mentally pictured to myself the image of the subject M. asleep. The latter, according to the statements of those present, did indeed almost at once break off her conversation with Bekhterev and fall asleep.

The awakening was produced in the same way, i.e. by my mentally picturing the figure of the subject M. waking from sleep. This experiment was repeated three times, with equal success. To the questions afterwards put by those present: “What happened to you just now?” — the subject M. replied: “I don't know, I think I was asleep.” — “Why did you fall asleep?” — “Oh, I just felt like sleeping.”

It is important to note that when I acted on the subject in the form of a mental command: “Go to sleep! Sleep!” — the latter was always without result. But when I visually pictured the image and figure of M. asleep (or of M. awake), the effect was always positive.

As regards the special personal characteristics of the subject M., I can say that she was my patient; she proved to be a good somnambulist and was very highly suggestible. I first met her a year before that, in 1923, at the Slavyansk resort, where I was working as a consultant on nervous diseases and where I demonstrated on the patient M. a series of ordinary hypnosuggestive investigations. By that time I was already acquainted with the method of “mental suggestion”. It was this method that I tried out in experiments with M., who quite unexpectedly gave a positive effect of putting to sleep by means of my merely mentally picturing the visual image of M. asleep. At that same time I became convinced that this effect could not be obtained by a mental command to fall asleep, whereas the visual picturing that I employed proved fully effective. 189It should be noted that the effect of awakening M. likewise arose quite suddenly, a few seconds after the beginning of my mental picturing of her awakening.

These experiments of mine were carried out at that time with the participation of my son, the biologist K. K. Platonov. He recorded the duration of the latent period between the beginning of my mental picturing of her falling asleep (or awakening) and the moment the corresponding effect arose. It proved to be equal to a few seconds.

It should be observed that M. fell asleep not only when she was in a calm state but also during a conversation with someone. Once I put her to sleep in this way while she was waltzing to the sounds of a piano. Moreover, I could be not beside her but at a considerable distance from her, even outside the house in which she was. All this greatly astonished us and the other physicians of the resort.

With all this it must be particularly emphasized that M. was entirely unaware of the content of the experiments in putting to sleep that were carried out with her. These were performed without her knowledge and without any preliminary conversations on the subject. Thus she was not informed of the nature of the experimentation, and she herself had no idea of the cause of her falling asleep.

On arriving in Leningrad in December 1924 for the congress, I happened to meet in Leningrad Citizen M., who turned out to be a resident of Leningrad. She willingly agreed to attend the congress with me and to be present at a session that would be of interest to her. Nothing was said to her about the purpose of her attending the congress.

After the demonstration at the congress described above, she asked me in bewilderment: “Why did you invite me to the congress? I don't understand it. What was done to me? I was asleep, but I don't know why. After all, you did not put me to sleep!”

Thus at the congress we confined ourselves merely to demonstrating an incomprehensible and puzzling phenomenon, doubtful to the majority of the audience, the members of the congress, and admissible to recognition only by a few individual persons. The phenomena observed in our experiments were so striking in their clarity and constancy that one could not but acknowledge their reality.

Subsequently, after the congress, the subject M. was for some time the subject of investigation by the physiologist L. L. Vasiliev, who had been present at our demonstrations at the congress. These demonstrations served L. L. Vasiliev as a stimulus to the serious study of the phenomena of telepathy, expressed, as is well known, in the form of transmission of thought at a distance. The numerous further investigations in this direction carried out by L. L. Vasiliev (1926–1960), with a positive result of mental putting to sleep and awakening at a distance, compel one to treat this phenomenon with all seriousness. Recently 190L. L. Vasiliev wrote to us that, of his numerous experiments on telepathy, it is precisely putting to sleep at a distance that stands in first place both in success and in number.

In our opinion, all these data may help towards recognition of the reality of mental putting to sleep at a distance, obtained with very rarely encountered subjects. At the same time they give us the right to seek ways of a scientific, materialist explanation not only of these phenomena of tele-sleep induction but also of many other, more complex phenomena of telepathy.

Evidently, favourable conditions are now being created for the study of these hitherto “mysterious” phenomena of telepathy. Until now the basis of this phenomenon was taken to be the doctrine of the electrical processes occurring in the brain. It was considered that the brain produces various electromagnetic waves. But recently the supposition has arisen that the carrier of telepathy may be “a physical field new to science, produced by the brain”.

Nevertheless, it must be considered that the solution of the extremely complex problem of “transmission of thought at a distance” is at present still at the very initial stage of scientific investigation.

Let us permit ourselves to put forward our own supposition as well regarding the nature of the phenomena of mental putting to sleep at a distance that interest us, a supposition which follows from the method of tele-sleep induction we employed.

First of all it should be noted that in our experiments the influence was exerted by means of visual picturing, i.e. with the participation of the cortical mechanisms connected with the visual analyzer, whereas in the usually practised mental suggestion it is the cortical mechanism connected with the speech-motor analyzer that is brought into action.

If one recognizes the existence of visual telepathic dreams, encountered in certain persons, the thought involuntarily arises that these phenomena are similar in their mechanism of formation by means of the cortical part of the visual analyzer. The mechanism by which these dreams arise may also be regarded from the standpoint of the doctrine of the electrical processes occurring in the brain, with electrical waves emanating from the cerebral cortex. Accordingly, the source of these dreams could be the brain of another person who had experienced some unusually strong emotion and who, moreover, was related to the given person or stood in other close relations with him.

Along with this, the idea may be put forward that there is an analogy between cerebral television and the mechanism of modern television communication, the television screen being comparable to the brain substance of the percipient in the tele-sleep induction experiment. All this is, of course, hypothetical, but perhaps it will in time be taken into account. After all, a television set also reflects reality on its screen by means of radio communication. 191Nor can one fail to take into account the fact that the manuals on suggestion mention not only verbal suggestion but also visual suggestion. Accordingly, may not the phenomenon under consideration be based on an influence emanating from the visual zone of the inductor's cerebral cortex, since the idea of falling asleep and awakening was in my case, as the inductor, connected precisely with the visual image of the subject?

By virtue of this, in the tele-sleep induction experiments there is apparently ground for speaking of a mechanism of suggestion through an influence exerted by the cortical part of the visual analyzer (i.e. not the speech-motor, not the verbal one).

I would remark that some of the speakers at the Kharkov debate on telepathy apparently supposed that the phenomena of mental suggestion are connected with the doctrine of hypnosis and verbal suggestion. Prof. N. P. Tatarenko, who spoke in the discussion at this debate, rightly denied this connection. Of course, the phenomena of telepathy, hypnosis and verbal suggestion are, in their essence, entirely different.

The above reasoning about an analogy with ordinary television may perhaps help the matter: sometimes the method of analogy proves useful. At a certain stage of the struggle for scientific truth, conclusions by analogy are also admissible.

K. I. Platonov

Appendix 6

ON THE EXPERIMENTS IN MENTAL SUGGESTION OF SLEEP AND AWAKENING CARRIED OUT BY SCIENTISTS OF KHARKOV UNIVERSITY

Letter from Prof. K. I. Platonov to L. L. Vasiliev, Kharkov, 31 Jan. 1961

Dear Leonid Leonidovich! After my return from Leningrad in 1924, where I had demonstrated at the congress my experiment in the transmission of thought at a distance — chiefly mental putting to sleep and awakening — analogous experiments were carried out in Kharkov by one of the physicians who followed me in the doctrine of hypnosis and suggestion. I am forwarding to you the information about these experiments, which I received from the physician Konstantin Dmitrievich Kotkov, an active participant in these experiments. Unfortunately, as you will see for yourself, the matter is limited to information only. But all the same, it seems to me, this information will not be superfluous for you. I was informed about these experiments and took some part in them as a consultant, inasmuch as these three experimenters (one of them a physicist of the Faculty of Natural Sciences and two physicians — an endocrinologist and a psychotherapist) had been listeners at my report and witnesses of my demonstration in 1924 in Leningrad. 192I, too, had records of the Kharkov experiments with Mikhailova, but they have vanished without a trace. You wrote to me that your greatest successes were with mental putting to sleep. Evidently there is a regularity in this.

This is what I wished to share with you, dear Leonid Leonidovich. I firmly shake your hand and embrace you. Herewith I enclose the letter of Dr. K. D. Kotkov.

Yours, K. Platonov

Letter from the physician K. D. Kotkov to Prof. K. I. Platonov, January 1961

Dear Konstantin Ivanovich! In 1924 A. V. Zhelikhovsky, professor of physics at Kharkov University, and the chemist Dr. L. R. Normark carried out a small but very interesting piece of work on the transmission of thought to a distance. Its chief initiator, its soul, was Normark. I was invited by them to take part in this work as an experimenter. For this reason they kept all the protocols. I, unfortunately, did not think of making copies for myself. Zhelikhovsky died during the occupation of Kharkov by the Germans, and of Normark's recent death I learned from you at our last meeting. Thus there is no one from whom the protocols of this remarkable work can be obtained. Their fate is unknown to me.

I know that my communications, without exact protocols, have no value whatsoever, being unsubstantiated, but all the same I wish to give them to you. If they prove of use to you for anything at all, even in some small measure, I shall be very glad.

A few words about the subject. A woman student of the university, 18–19 years old, perfectly healthy, of changeable mood but more melancholic. An excellent somnambulist. In Normark's laboratory, in the presence of students, I had demonstrated to him with her truly astonishing experiments in suggestion. Zhelikhovsky and Normark invited me to be the experimenter in their work. I settled my choice of subject on this girl. But how were we to proceed?

We considered it impossible to experiment on her without her knowledge. We approached her for permission. She readily agreed. She knew that over a period of 2–3 months we would be carrying out experiments on her, but when, i.e. on what days and at what hours, how, and what experiments exactly, she did not know.

She fell asleep instantly under the influence of the suggestions transmitted to her mentally, and under the influence of mental suggestions she likewise awoke instantly. She remembered nothing. Here is an example: once, at Zhelikhovsky's flat, she fell asleep standing, at a moment when she was holding high in front of her and examining with great interest some preparation in a phial that Zhelikhovsky had handed her. When she awoke, she went on examining it as if nothing had happened, and sharing her 193impressions with the professor, continuing her conversation with him from the interrupted thought. Repeatedly she turned to us with the question: “When are the experiments you warned me about going to begin?” To this she was usually answered: “Let us wait a little longer. The apparatus is not ready.” So from the very beginning of the experiments to their very end she never learned whether experiments had been carried out on her or not, and what sort of experiments they were. Afterwards she went away, and I lost sight of her.

A few words about my method of transmitting thoughts: I would sit down in a comfortable armchair, in absolute silence. I would close my eyes. Mentally I whispered to my subject the words of suggestion: “Sleep! Sleep! Sleep!..” This I shall call the first factor of mental suggestion.

The second factor. I pictured to myself the image of the subject to the point of hallucination or of the most vivid dreamlike quality. I pictured her in my imagination deeply asleep, with her eyes closed.

And, finally, the third factor. I consider it the most important. I shall call it the will factor. I strongly desired that the girl should fall asleep. At last this desire passed into a certainty that she was already asleep and into a peculiar sort of “ecstasy of triumphant success”. I signalled this moment and stopped the experiment. The time was precisely recorded. I waited for the signal to begin the awakening and carried it out by the same method. Again I signalled the awakening of the subject. She also awoke at the moment of my signal. All three of these factors acted simultaneously for a duration of 3–5 minutes.

Not many experiments were carried out, no more than thirty. Of these, not a single one was unsuccessful. The intervals between them were from one to three days. And sometimes two days running.

We carried out experiments not only on putting to sleep and awakening, but also on summoning the subject. While in my own flat, at a time strictly agreed upon with Zhelikhovsky and Normark, I would summon the girl to Normark's laboratory, using the same method. When the “ecstasy of triumphant success” set in, I stopped the experiment and went to the laboratory. Usually I either found the girl already there, or she arrived a little after I did. When she was asked why she had come, she usually answered in embarrassment: “I don't know... Just so... I felt like coming...”

None of us doubted that the transmission of thought is possible. Our aim was to confirm this possibility and, above all, to determine the nature of the energy that is radiated by the brain in the process.

The subject was invited to the experiments on pretexts that could not lead her attention to any guesses as to why she had been invited. During the experiment the girl's attention was occupied to the utmost with everything with which it was at all possible to occupy it. She was given no opportunity to concentrate on anything on her own.

The first experiments were carried out in one building. We were separated by several rooms. Then we went over to experiments in which we 194were at opposite ends of the city. The success was the same. Communication was so well organized that not a single minute of observation was lost. Everything was recorded in the most precise manner.

The second half of the experiments was carried out with apparatus. I was placed in a sort of specially constructed cabin, isolating me from the entire outside world. The aim was not to let the radiations of the brain pass through its walls. As need arose, the necessary changes were made in the equipment of the cabin, and the experiments continued. Mental suggestion succeeded equally and invariably, with astonishing accuracy and speed.

Only one defect in this work equally troubled all three of us. This was that the girl had nevertheless been forewarned about the experiments. But everything was done so skilfully and carefully that she did not know about the experiments. This was proved by the fact that up to the very last moment, up to the very last experiment, she kept asking us when, at last, the experiments with her would begin.

Normark and Zhelikhovsky came to definite conclusions about the possibility of transmission of thought at a distance without the aid of the sense organs, directly from one brain to another, by means of radiations of the brain during its thinking activity and the action of these radiations on the brain of the subject. They also came to definite conclusions about the nature of these radiations, but everything remained in the materials of the investigation — in the protocols of the experiments and the conclusions of the authors.

After the work had been carried out, in the same year, Zhelikhovsky gave a special report at a scientific conference of physicists which was held at Kharkov University. The work was to have been published somewhere, but I know nothing of its subsequent fate.

This, unfortunately, is the little that I can say, If anything should need to be added, I shall be glad to do so for you.

Respectfully yours, Dr. K. Kotkov

Appendix 7

PARAPSYCHOLOGY IN RUSSIA

Editorial in the bulletin published by Dr. J. B. Rhine's parapsychology laboratory at Duke University, USA (No. 57, May 1961, p. 1).10 (Parapsychology Bulletin, N 57, May 1961, p. 1, Duke University, USA)

The Western world has had to revise its opinion of science in the USSR in recent years. A second event, this time 195connected not with the conquest of space but rather with the nature of man himself, will again have to be credited to Soviet science. But whereas most astrophysicists undoubtedly foresaw that it would be Russia that would send the first man into space, no Western parapsychologist foresaw that it would be precisely a Russian university that would be the first to establish a state-financed parapsychological research laboratory.

Nevertheless this happened last year at Leningrad State University on the initiative of Prof. L. L. Vasiliev, head of the Department of Physiology and corresponding member of the Academy of Medical Sciences. What this laboratory is engaged in bears the name of “bioelectronics”, “brain communication” or, in free translation, “mental radio”.

The popular-science journal Znanie—Sila in Moscow in 1961 published an account of the materials of a seminar held at Leningrad University, at which Prof. L. L. Vasiliev and his colleagues (among them Prof. P. V. Terentiev) gave reports on Russian research in this field. Professor Vasiliev worked with the late eminent physiologist Prof. V. M. Bekhterev (see Journal of Parapsychology, September 1949,11 an article on Bekhterev's telepathic experiments with dogs) and with Prof. P. P. Lazarev on experiments on the transmission of thoughts. Later, in the early thirties, Vasiliev and his colleagues carried out experiments on telepathy in which the subjects were in a hypnotic state, the hypnotist and the subject being placed in different rooms.

Successful demonstrations were carried out, including the telepathic induction of the hypnotic state. The experiments were successful even when the subjects were in a lead chamber with an entrance hatch that was lowered into a mercury trough. The experimenters came to the conclusion that the hypothesis that electromagnetic radiation underlies the transmission of thoughts must be abandoned.

The investigators report that the results seemed to them so puzzling that it was only last year that it was decided to publish them and to open a scientific discussion.12 Then experiments were begun using modern methods.

The published statements of representatives of Russian scientists concerning the data examined at the symposium13 apparently resemble the opinions of Western scientists on the results of experiments in extrasensory perception (ESP). 196Some consider such results impossible on the grounds that there is no acceptable physical theory that could explain them. Others consider that the experiments should be continued and the facts accumulated and assessed according to their quality.

Thus it is still the same old split between those who require an acceptable theory and those who do not need one in order to recognize a new fact — between conservatives and progressive scientists. That is how all new data are always received.

Strange as it may seem, the impetus for the appearance of the Russian article in print was a report of an American experiment that we have been unable to confirm.

This was a report, printed in one of the French journals, that spoke of experiments in ESP. During the experiments the subject was in a submarine. Authoritative persons in Washington state that they know nothing of any such experiment.

Parapsychologists in other countries will await with interest reports both on the earlier Leningrad experiments and on the new research programme.

Appendix 8

LETTER TO PROF. L. L. VASILIEV FROM THE PARAPSYCHOLOGIST STEPHEN ABRAMS

(University of Oxford, Department of Biometry)

16 October 1961

Dear Professor Vasiliev,

I regret that I did not reply at once to your letter of 20 June. I spent the summer in the USA and therefore received it much later. On the way back to England, aboard the “Liberté”, I discovered an excellent hypnotizable subject and was able to repeat some of your experiments on the suggestion of sleep and awakening at a distance. My experiment was of a purely exploratory character, and I am not entirely satisfied with the controls that I applied. But I am encouraged and am planning further research in this field in the near future. As soon as I am able to work out the basic experimental designs, I shall write to you about them in more detail. I shall be grateful for any comments of yours.

My information about your work has been obtained almost exclusively from the article in the journal “Znanie—Sila” (translated in “The Soviet Review”) and from Dr. Ryzl's article in the latest issue of the Journal of Parapsychology. I am interested to know how far you and 197your colleagues are informed about the state of parapsychology and psychical research in the West. Perhaps I could be of help to you by informing you from time to time about serious investigators and about material deserving your attention. It is rather difficult to assess such research unless one is in the thick of it and has access to a mass of published and unpublished data, knows most of the leading investigators personally and, having every opportunity, follows the progress of work in this direction.

As regards hypnosis at a distance, I am interested to know whether you are acquainted with the research on this question carried out in France in the last century. You undoubtedly know the remarkable work of Pierre Janet and Charles Richet with Léonie B. This work evidently inspired you to carry out your research of the thirties.

I am prepared to come to Leningrad to talk with you, but I think that I ought first to conduct a series of experiments using your methods. January seems to me a suitable time, though I could come earlier or later. If it would be of interest to you, I should be glad to give a talk or a seminar at your institution on the present state of the problem of extrasensory perception.

Please let me know whether I can do anything useful for you.

Sincerely yours,

Stephen I. Abrams

Notes

  1. Apparently A. G. Kozhevnikov, professor of zoology at Moscow University, who took an active part in V. L. Durov's experiments on mental influence on trained dogs (my note.— L. V.). ↩
  2. Italics by V. F. Mitkevich. ↩
  3. J. Ochorowicz. De la suggestion mentale. Paris, 1887. ↩
  4. In his book of 1887 just mentioned. ↩
  5. A. Binet. Revue des Deux-Mondes, 1893, 15 Mars, p. 443. ↩
  6. F. Myers. Human Personality, New Impression. London, 1909, p. 382. 5: See C. Flammarion. L'Inconnu et les problèmes psychiques. Paris, 1900; K. Flammarion. The Unknown. Various Phenomena in the Domain of Psychism (in Russian). St. Petersburg, 1901. ↩
  7. See more detailed surveys of the literature on the question of hypnotization at a distance: J.-Ch. Roux. Expériences françaises récontes de suggestion mentale, de clairvoyance et d'hypnotisation à distance. Annales des Sciences psychiquees, juillet-août, 1893; F. Podmore. Apparitions and Thought Transference. London a. New York, 1915; Ch. Richet. Traité de métapsychique, deuxième édition refondue. Paris, 1923, pp. 25–26 et 126–128. ↩
  8. This article was sent at my request by K. I. Platonov for inclusion in the appendices to the present book (my note.—L. V.). ↩
  9. I have already mentioned this demonstration of experiments in the mental suggestion of sleep and awakening in the subject Mikhailova on pp. 97–98 (my note. — L. V.). ↩
  10. Translated by E. A. Lenz. ↩
  11. Journal of Parapsychology, 1949, September. ↩
  12. An English translation of the articles relating to this discussion in the journal “Znanie—Sila” appeared in the June issue of the journal “The Soviet Review” (New York, 1961). My experiments are described in more detail in the article: M. Rýzl. Research on Telepathy in Soviet Russia. Journ. of Parapsychology, 1961, v. 25, No 2, p. 75 (my note.— L. V.). ↩
  13. The reference is to the discussion in the journal “Znanie—Sila” (my note. — L. V.). ↩